PHSSL District 1 2 3 16 Qualifier
2021 — NSDA Campus, PA/US
01 - Public Forum Paradigm List
All Paradigms: Show HideI am a traditional judge from a traditional area of the country. I competed in LD, PF, Congress, Extemp, and other events when I was in high school in 2003-2006. I went to American University for undergrad and obtained a BA in Political Science (with a concentration in political theory) and Philosophy. I then went to law school and I am presently a practicing public defender in Pittsburgh. I have judged debate events sporadically since I graduated from high school.
I focus on the clarity and consistency of the argument, with technique trumping the truth of the argument. I am not a strict flow judge and expect that extensions of arguments will be supported by more than a conclusory statement that the debater has prevailed on that particular argument. I prefer to have clear voting issues at the end of the round in order to prevail.
I am very familiar with theory and will most likely be aware of any theoretical arguments you make. I am less familiar with kritick arguments, but I will entertain them.
I have no tolerance for rude and insulting behavior toward your opponent and will deduct speaking points accordingly. I do not consider it rude or insulting for the cross examining party to cut off someone who is filibustering rather than answering a question.