In addition to overall skill (pace, tone, clarity, etc.) I look for a clear understanding of a debater's own unique contentions. Both rebuffing your opponent's points and defending your own are critical.

Hi. My name is Laura Worrel. I am very much a lay judge but have been judging public forum for a couple of years. I prefer organized speeches that I can understand. Please make it very clear why I should vote for you. I will try my best to flow and make an informed decision. Thanks!