Background:

I've been doing debate for 6 years. I'm on the Varsity PF debate team at Thomas Jefferson High School.

PF Debate:

Tech ---x------- Truth

Clarity X---------- Who doesn't like clarity

- Respond to first rebuttal turns in second rebuttal or it's too late

- Extend the warrant and impact of argument(s) in later speeches

- Please no theory or Ks

Speed:

- I can only write down things so fast so keep that in mind

- Signpost so I know what you're talking about

As a Russian and Ukrainian, I stand with Ukraine.

MS debate

Parliamentary debate:

I will flow pretty much everything you say in the round to the best of my ability. I can handle speed but not spreading (300+ WPM) without getting a speech document. Off-time roadmaps are fine. Assume I don't know the nuances about the topic you are debating, so if your arguments are complex, be sure to explain them well.

Framework/Definitions: If a framework isn't mentioned, I will default to the resolution and choose which side does more benefits/harms. The 1st prop can choose to define terms in the resolution, but it is not required. If the definitions are unreasonable, the opp can propose their own definitions, but please provide a reason about why you think they are unreasonable.

New Arguments: I won't accept any brand new arguments in the last two speeches unless the 3rd prop, the very last speech, is responding to new arguments made by the 2nd and 3rd opp speeches. That being said, feel free to elaborate on arguments you've already made.

Weighing: It's super important to weigh the arguments at the end of the round. This means explaining why, even if I believe all the arguments made by both sides, your team would still win the round.

Speaker points: At the end of tournaments, my speaker points usually range between 67-83. Eloquence, body language, taking POIs, and a touch of humor in your speeches will help your speaker points while rudeness will hurt them.

If you have any questions, please ask them before the round. I will disclose my decision in detail at the end of the round. Most importantly, have fun! :)

Please slow down. Speaking fast does not enhance your argument.

Please be mindful of time. I will show a yellow card when 60 seconds remaining and a pink card when you time is up. Please do not run over.

I would not be offended if you make inquiries about the process -- I have only judged a couple of times before. Your help with the process is appreciated.

I will make comments on the ballots. I may or may not have time to give extensive verbal feedback.

Good luck to you all.

I competed in PF for 4 years for Whitman.

Likes:

Strong warrants, common sense, narrative, weighing, analytics, lay appeal, strategic collapsing, nuanced/creative arguments, frontlining in second rebuttal, slow final focus, actual clash

Dislikes:

Squirrelly arguments, progressive args/framing/theory, speaking really quickly, unsubstantiated claims/weighing, new offense after rebuttal, rudeness/making things personal

Respect is top priority. If you don't respect your opponents you will lose the round.

Pronouns she/her

Preferences:

Speed is fine but make sure what you're saying is clear; enunciate your words

Eye contact is important, but I understand if you can't do so, as we are in a virtual setting

It's recommended that you keep your own time- I will keep time as well

Please roadmap your speeches, as I will be flowing. Make it clear to me what you are talking about

Weighing is crucial and will be a huge part of my decision as to who won or lost

I will give personal feedback to every speaker.

Use up all or as much as possible of your time- it tells me you have a lot to say and adds to your case

Obviously, be respectful to both your teammates and your opponents. No interrupting others

Things that will help me decide the win- weighing, impacts, and rebuttals.

May the odds ever be in your favor :)