.

I am a parent judge and this is my 3rd year judging PF and LD.

Most rounds that I have judged in the past are very close calls, never an easy / clear-cut decision. So, I take a lot of notes during the rounds, and take time reflecting on both sides before making a final decision. And so a not-too-crazy speed of delivery works best for me. If you go super-fast, you might lose me.

Also, a good set of definitions at the beginning of the debate has been helpful for me in following along on some of the not-too-familiar topics.

I am also not a big fan of teams who use sarcasm or overly aggressive speech to put down their opponents. I value a healthy and respectful debate. So the team who is able to defend their values while attacking their opponent’s case in an effective, yet respectful manner usually wins my vote!

Happy Debating!!

Hello,

I am a volunteer judge for my son's school in speech and debate events. Like most mercenaries, I go when and where I am asked. I am a trial by fire judge for better or worse. I have little to no formal training in speech or debate. Send me a short PDF or video clip and voila, I'm the expert. Well maybe not the expert, but I judge objectively. Hopefully my comments and clear and helpful.

Speech Events: Novice Reading, Story Telling, Dramatic/Humorous/Duo Interpretation, Declamation, Extemporaneous/Informative/Impromptu Speaking

Compulsories - adhere to any event compulsories. Cite titles and authors of reference pieces. Read from script if required, even if you know it by heart. Follow, but don't be afraid to stretch (grace period), time limits.

Vocal - Speak in articulate ??? at a pace that is easy to follow. Vary pace in an appropriate manor, but do not loose control of enunciation.

Physical - Comfortably use as much of the room as possible if movement is allowed. Keep one foot planted if movement is restricted. Always use facial animations and craft grand gestures to emphasize important moments of your performance.

Debate

Lincoln Douglas

Public Forum