VCFL 4
2021
—
Online,
VA/US
PF Debate Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Kevin Bresnahan
Smithfield High School
None
Rajesh Chintkuntlawar
Mills E. Godwin High School
None
Jessie Cline
Woodberry Forest School
None
Kiko Demetriou
Clover Hill High School
Last changed on
Thu February 6, 2020 at 4:24 PM EDT
Speaks: based on organization and time allocation
Summary: 1. if it's not said in this speech i wont flow it to the FF.
2. Collapse down to fewer contentions, and explain why they drop off the flow (wash, block, etc.), but still go line by line as much as possible.
FF- 1. Give me big picture themes that the round has collapsed to. Not just your voters and their voters, collapse on the round as a whole, big picture.
*I dont flow CX so say it again in speech if its important
** I'm ok with speed, but go easy on me its been a few years
*** I HATE EVIDENCE DEBATES. If there is even in the slightest a voter issue/arg in the round relying on the properly cut evidence, then i will call to see the card. I will treat it as a reverse voting issue if the accusing side is wrong to disincentivize wild accusations.
Amanda Gum
Smithfield High School
8 rounds
None
Susan Mahlburg
Charlottesville High School
Last changed on
Fri December 1, 2017 at 9:39 AM EDT
I almost exclusively judge Varsity LD and have done so for a few years. I am looking for a debate with a clear value clash and a logical framework. Feel free to run theory. I can keep up with a fast flow, but don't let speed impede your meaning or clarity. I enjoy a good cross-x. Play nice and have fun.
Nathan Munson
Jefferson Forest High School
None
Roxanne Roberson-Nay
Mills E. Godwin High School
None
Rachit Shah
Maggie L. Walker Governor's School
Last changed on
Sat February 13, 2021 at 2:30 AM EDT
Please do not spread. Please roadmap before you begin.
Dave Shine
Maggie L. Walker Governor's School
Last changed on
Sat April 6, 2024 at 7:04 AM EDT
I am a former competitor in high school, college and grad school. I've been judging debate for twenty plus years. Most experience has been in LD but last six years I've judged plenty of public forum. If I can not understand your argument because of speeding it is not valid. So, no speeding. Need clash of arguments or very tech decision. Do not let the round come down to a definition debate.
Andrea Tarbox
Louisa County High School
None
Jennifer Timms
Monticello High School
None
Darian Wyatt
Cosby High School
Last changed on
Sat January 13, 2024 at 3:41 AM EDT
Not a lay judge, PF state title holder. Lots of CX and LD experience, so speed is fine with me. To me, clash is very important for all debate types, so make it strong.