2021 NYCUDL HS AND MS 5
2021
—
Online,
NY/US
PF HS Varsity Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Claire Balani
Hire
8 rounds
None
Erin Black
BSGE Debate Team
None
Burt Bloom
Hire
8 rounds
None
Rich Cadigan
Westfield Debate Team
None
Jacob Cano
Yonkers Partners in Education
None
Jason Cano
Yonkers Partners in Education
None
Last changed on
Sat February 17, 2024 at 10:22 AM CDT
Carlos
I debated at Washburn University (LD)
No topic experience!
Email chain: aegfew@gmail.com
LD in college is pretty much a condensed policy round.
TL-DR: I evaluate the round through risk analysisLike to think I have no biases so do what you want. I default to evidence quality when clash is very close. Me adapting to you>>> you adapting to me. Want to see you at your best.
Speed- Bueno
Case: Impact turns are bueno. Impact calc! 2ACs should extend case, 2AR not so much.
FW: If you don't clash don't get mad when I have to intervene
DAs: bueno
T: The standards debate will dictate the ballot- will not vote on gut checks and a risk of offense on competing interps means the aff is unreasonable
Theory: idc
K: do whatever
CP: Perms should be more than perm do both. On PICS, Consult, Delay I lean neg on theory but i weigh solvency deficits heavily for the aff
Speaks: 28.5 is middle
be nice
Patrick Cicala
Westfield Debate Team
None
Iriss Clymer
World View High School
None
Gail Elaine Crooks
Bard High School Early College Queens
Last changed on
Wed October 2, 2019 at 10:19 AM EDT
I weigh heavily on impacts & flowing arguments through. I can handle fast speaking but not spreading. I don’t flow crossfire but I will be paying attention. Collapse on your impacts in summary first and revisit them in final focus. Summary is important for weighing! Be respectful, be clear with your points. Don't stare at me.
Evan D'Amaso
Hire
8 rounds
Last changed on
Sun October 9, 2022 at 7:31 AM EDT
The key for me when it comes to deciding most debates is two fold. First it is easier for me to vote for a team that weighs what is is being debated instead of just continuing to reiterate what their argument is. Well argued impacts are essential to choosing who is doing the better debating. I will look at the round objectively regardless of what I personally believe in almost every case so the way you frame your arguments and position them in the real world is very important to me.
Second, I think that since I am on the other side of the round, all I have to go on is what you're giving me; I will not do the work for you. In other words, if you make a really convincing argument in the first speech or in cross fire and you don't extend through the entire debate it or you let the other team take out the impacts without you addressing them, I can't just ignore that they're doing the better debating just because you may be right. I hope that makes sense.
As for me, I have a mostly policy background as a debater so I am good with spreading or k debate if you want to take it there, I have no real preference of specific arguments, i will hear whatever you say to me and weigh it as such. Just be respectful of everyone's space and time to speak, don't be an a**hole, and truly most importantly, have fun. I'm dead serious, if you're not having It'll just be a rough time for everyone, energies are tangible even over zoom.
Katelijne De Backer
BASIS Independent Brooklyn
None
Lori Donnelley
Westfield Debate Team
8 rounds
Last changed on
Sat January 13, 2024 at 3:32 AM EDT
I’m a parent judge who has judged PF for four years. This paradigm was influenced by my son. I flow important points throughout the round.
Preferences:
-
Have both warrants and impacts backed up by evidence in your case. Carry them through the round if you want me to vote on them.
-
Do comparative weighing in summary AND final focus, this is important. Don’t use buzzwords.
-
If you want me to vote on an argument, it must be in summary AND final focus.
-
Don’t speak too quickly. If I can’t understand you, you won’t win my ballot.
-
Be respectful, especially in crossfire, or I will dock speaker points.
-
No new arguments in final focus, they will not be considered. Bring them up earlier in the round so your opponents can respond to them.
-
Have all evidence ready to show your opponents. Don’t take too long when evidence is asked for..
-
Signpost throughout your speeches. This also includes short offtime roadmaps. It makes it much easier to flow.
-
Clearly explain your arguments in each speech, do not just assume I have a prior understanding of every argument. I do some reading on the topic before the tournament, but I am by no means an expert.
-
Don’t run progressive arguments (Ks, theory), I don’t know how to evaluate them.
Speaker Points (adjusted based on division):
<26: Very poor OR offensive, rude, tried to cheat, etc.
26-26.9: Below Average
27-27.9: Average
28-28.9: Above Average
29-29.5: Great
29.6-30: Amazing
Tania Fadhel
IN-Tech Academy, MS/HS 368x
None
Luke Feder
The Browning School
None
Erin Finnigan
Special Music School
None
Kristine Fitzpatrick
Midwood High School
None
Paul Glenn
Brooklyn Technical High School
Last changed on
Fri February 2, 2024 at 11:21 AM EDT
Previous coach, tab director (be on time!), and judge of long ago. Never debated. I can flow arguments made at slightly above conversational pace and appreciate when winning arguments are made clear enough that I don't have to think too hard.
- Don't time torch the round - there are guidelines in the Live Doc about prep time deduction if your evidence takes an excessive amount of time to find. You should be able to find your cards within ten to fifteen seconds in our digital age. Use hyperlinks to your advantage!
- There are also specifications about no prep during evidence finding since, if it's as fast as it should be, that time isn't deducted from prep.
Theory: Debate is a game that should be equitable, educational, and played respectfully. I'll listen to arguments that impact to the shortfalls of the debate space in any of those domains.
David Kaufman
Hire
8 rounds
None
Julie Kuang
Hire
8 rounds
Last changed on
Sat March 2, 2024 at 3:20 AM EDT
** Assume that I am a flow judge, but lay on the topic
If you want me to vote on an argument, it has to be in summary and final focus.
I appreciate world comparisons, weighing, and logically explained arguments.
I do not like speed. I will not flow your arguments if I do not understand what you are saying.
I will decide your speaks based on the clarity and content of your speech.
In general
***Before you start your speech tell me which side of the flow you are starting on, and sign post clearly as you go along.
***Don't be a jerk.
***Please do not shake my hand.
Lauren Levy
High School of American Studies
None
Susan Lopez
Fiorello H Laguardia High School
None
Elizabeth Miller
High School of American Studies
None
Emil Moffa
Hire
8 rounds
None
Melodie Ting
The Browning School
Last changed on
Mon March 4, 2024 at 5:03 AM EDT
Background: I debated Parli in High School and College. I am currently a coach for PF, have been judging PF ever since
-I don't mind speed, just speak clearly
-Time yourself, I will also keep time and will stop flowing when you run out of time
-I do prefer when you stand when giving speeches
-I vote on impacts. Provide warrants and evidence for your claims. Extend these through final focus.
-Please cut your cards in advance - if you can't find your card quickly, I will assume it does not exist and strike it from my flow
-I expect you to frontline, and please weigh in final focus
-I will not flow crossfire, if it is important bring it back in your speeches.
-Please signpost, makes flow easy
Please send all evidence and speeches to mgt2130@columbia.edu
Wali Ullah
Brooklyn Technical High School
None
Tiffany Wade
Hire
8 rounds
None
Kristen Wilson
Westfield Debate Team
Last changed on
Sat March 5, 2022 at 12:43 PM EDT
I am a parent judge. I will judge based on a combination of the flow, general logic, strength of contentions and common sense.
Please do not run critiques in my rounds.
Please don't speak too fast. I can't appreciate your evidence if I can't understand it.
Be respectful to other competitors.
Good luck and have fun!
AJ Yablonsky
Hire
8 rounds
None