ASDA Winter Trophy
2026 — Tempe, AZ/US
World Schools Debate
Event Description:
Rounds 1 and 2 Motion: This House prefers expanding universal basic services to introducing a universal basic income.
Info slide: Universal basic services involve governments providing essential goods and services such as transportation, childcare, internet access, or housing at little or no direct cost, rather than providing unrestricted cash payments.
Round 3 and Semis will be impromptu motions.
Each debater will deliver a substantive speech presenting their team's arguments and engaging with the opposing team's case. These speeches are eight minutes long. The Proposition will always speak first, followed by the Opposition. Speakers should establish their arguments, provide relevant examples and evidence, and respond directly to their opponents' claims.
Proposition Speaker 1 – 8 minutes
Opposition Speaker 1 – 8 minutes
Proposition Speaker 2 – 8 minutes
Opposition Speaker 2 – 8 minutes
Proposition Speaker 3 – 8 minutes
Opposition Speaker 3 – 8 minutes
Opposition Reply – 4 minutes
Proposition Reply – 4 minutes
During substantive speeches, Points of Information (POIs) may be offered by the opposing team. POIs may not be offered during the first minute or the last minute of a speech. Speakers may accept or decline POIs during the permitted time. POIs are not permitted during reply speeches.
Following the six substantive speeches, each team will deliver a Reply speech. These speeches summarize the central arguments and issues of the debate, explain the major areas of clash, and demonstrate why the speaker's team has won the round. Reply speeches should focus on the arguments and analysis presented earlier in the debate. No new substantive arguments may be introduced. The Opposition will deliver the first Reply speech, followed by the Proposition.
The Proposition and the Opposition
World Schools Debate is designed to encourage critical thinking, persuasive argumentation, and direct engagement between opposing viewpoints. The Proposition is expected to establish a persuasive case in favor of the motion. The Opposition must challenge the Proposition's arguments and demonstrate why the motion should be rejected. The Opposition should do more than simply disagree with the Proposition; it should develop its own analysis and engage directly with the central issues of the debate.
Both teams are expected to support their arguments with sound reasoning, relevant examples, and evidence where appropriate. Judges should evaluate the debate based on the quality of the arguments, rebuttal, engagement, analysis, and overall persuasiveness rather than their personal beliefs.
While AIA Tournament Rules will be the foundation for the operation of this tournament, please be advised that they will not apply in all situations. We have clearly noted any diversions from the AIA rules in the event information section. Event rules align with the NSDA.