New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament
2024 — New York, NY/US
Public Forum Debate Paradigm List
All Paradigms: Show HideHe/Him
email: prateek.motagi@stern.nyu.edu
lots of circuit experience (gtoc and more)
ask me anything before round!
tldr: run whatever, explain it, win!
disclosure is good (I mean for my decision, ofc)
-
Tech>Truth. I'll vote off ANYTHING extended cleanly on the flow. I was forced by my partner to love impact turns (do what you will with that). More on progressive stuff below.
-
Pleeeease read content warnings for potentially triggering args or u lose speaks (saves u from theory)
-
for novices- a content warning is when you read a warning for potentially harmful stuff in speech. for example, if I'm running solving domestic violence in my case, which some people could be uncomfortable debating about since that's an issue personal to them, I would say 'content warning: domestic violence' before constructive to notify them :)
- Tell me if you're in the bubble and I'll give you 30s
- If there is a lay or a flay on the panel, kick me. I'm fine with a nice, chill debate, and you should adapt to the majority!
Speeches
- Paraphrasing is chill, just don't lie about evidence. HOWEVER, I’m open to cut-card theory–I won’t intervene with my personal ideologies.
-
I'm fine with any speed, I don’t want to limit you as the judge. However, notify me before your speech so I know what to expect! I'll let you know if I need a doc or not.
-
Enunciate even if you're spreading, don't try to slur words to get more stuff out pls.
Rebuttal
-
You must frontline in 2nd rebuttal.
-
Independent DAs in 2nd rebuttal are sus, but responsive/overviews are fine.
Summary/FF
-
Must extend your link, impact, and clear warrant!!! (idc about author names I don't flow them)
Framework
-
Framework's cool! Please warrant it. Too many times, teams will just read a blip at the top of case saying “The fw for this debate should be how x will help in the future”
-
I GUESS I'll buy any framing. If it makes my head hurt then I will not vote off of it (this is maybe the most I’d intervene?)
Progressive
-
ngl idk much about prog
- I was not a theory debater
judge simp bad!