Annual Tournament of Hearts at Hallsville High
2023
—
Hallsville High School,
TX/US
Literary Criticism Judge Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Last changed on
Fri March 17, 2023 at 5:24 AM EDT
Per state rules, I believe teams should follow the set standards of formality. This includes, but is not limited to, maintaining a timely debate, not facing the opposing speakers and refraining from any implication of perceived abuse towards another speaker. Eye contact and speeches should be directed toward the judge only. Additionally, hard copies of a team's case must be presented to the opposing team upon request. Rapid fire delivery that inhibits effective communication will be penalized. In terms of Topicality, I believe in a tabula rasa approach, and feel that there is room to allow some deviation from original language, and provide metaphorical examples to support a case, within reason. Proof that the affirmative's plan is not in line the with the resolution will be held to a high standard.
Kyleigh Lopez
Marshall High School
None
Karen McGowan
Sabine High School
None