Carolina West District Tournament
2026 — NC/US
Carolina West District Qualifier
for the 2026 National Tournament
JUDGE GUIDELINES
Speech & Debate Judge Guide
At the tournament…
-
Bring paper, something to write with, a timing device, a computer or tablet, and something for entertainment in between rounds.
-
There is no need to dress up in formal attire.
-
Judges should stay in or near the Judge’s Lounge so that they don’t miss ballot calls, but most tournaments will use digital ballots, which will automatically load on Tabroom
To access your digital ballots…
-
Navigate to: www.tabroom.com and log into your account.
-
Once you’ve logged in, click your email address at the top of the screen to access your account page.
-
If you are judging this round, you should see a ballot posted. If you don’t, click the “Current Ballots & Panels” button just to double check.
When you get to the round...
-
Verify that you have the correct competitors:
-
Speech: Click the “START ROUND” button, then call roll. Go ahead and start the round with whomever is there, even if everyone is not present; some may be double entered.
-
LD/PF: Wait for both competitors/teams, then click “START ROUND” when all are present.
-
Ask a student to close the door, and begin the round...
-
Speech: Call competitors one at a time in the order listed on the ballot. Ask competitors if they would like time signals. Use your phone to time their speeches.
-
LD/PF: Instruct students which side to sit on (it’s generally easier to match the ballot). Students will time themselves, but you should use your phone to time them as well.
-
Congress: The Presiding Officer will call students and time speeches. Be sure to select the student’s name when they introduce themselves.
-
Remember to pay attention during the round… you should not be on your phone, etc. Give written feedback while students are speaking -- they are used to seeing their judge write. Be kind, but honest & constructive in your feedback. Most students won’t leave with trophies, but they will leave with your valuable feedback. There’s nothing worse than “great job - last place”
-
Don’t stress about your decision; students are used to new judges and know how to acclimate!
After the round...
-
You may submit comments for each speaker and an RFD (this is optional in speech, but really important in debate -- indicate which arguments you thought the winning team won)
-
Remember: no low point wins or equal points can be given. Try not to go below 22 speaker points in speech or 25 in debate (this is generally reserved for insulting or inappropriate behavior only).
-
Remember: If a speaker goes over 30-sec. grace time in a speech event, they can’t receive first place.
-
Once the round is done, enter the ranks, speaker points, etc. You will be asked to confirm your ballot.
-
You cannot change results after you enter them, but you can edit feedback. If you need more time to write comments, submit and edit your ballot later. It’s important that you submit at least the rankings promptly.
-
If there are any technical issues, let the coaches working in the tabulation room know.
-
Generally, no oral feedback, critiques, or disclosure of ranks is allowed in or after the round for speech events. In debate events, it is totally up to you whether you’d like to disclose.
Speech Events
|
Event Name: |
Timing: |
What to look for . . . |
|
Dramatic Interpretation Individual event where students perform a dramatic cutting of a single piece of literature. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Humorous Interpretation Individual event where students perform a humorous cutting of a single piece of literature. |
||
|
Duo Interpretation Two-person event where students perform a humorous or dramatic cutting of a single piece of literature. |
||
|
Program Oral Interpretation Individual event where students perform a program cut from selections of prose/poetry centered around a theme/topic/advocacy. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Extemporaneous Speaking Individual event where students draw 3 questions about current events, then select one, and bring it to the round. Students will take a stance and support it with evidence. |
7 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) judge MUST give time signals |
|
|
Impromptu Speaking Individual event where students select a topic and speak with little preparation. The student’s speech may be informative, humorous, or intended to convey an advocacy. |
judge provides 3 slips, then begins time after student chooses one 2 min. prep time 3-5 min. speaking (no grace period) |
|
|
Original Oratory Individual event where the student produces a short speech introducing an issue, problem, solution, and/or advocacy with researched evidence and personal anecdotes. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Informative Speaking Individual event where the student produces a short, researched speech informing the audience about a topic of their choosing. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Event Name: |
Timing: |
What to look for . . . |
|
Expository Individual event where the student produces a short, researched speech to describe, clarify, illustrate, or define an object, idea, concept, or process. |
5 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Children’s Literature Individual event where students select a published story from children’s literature that conveys a theme and retell it. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Declamation Individual event open to 9th and 10th graders only. Students deliver a previously-published speech. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Novice Reading Individual event open to first-year competitors only. Students select any published work (other than a play) and read the work dramatically. |
10 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
|
Storytelling Individual event generally open to first-year competitors only. Students select a published story from children’s literature that conveys a theme and retell it. |
5 min. max (w/ 30 sec. grace) |
|
Debate Events
|
Event Name: |
Timing: |
What to look for . . . |
|
Congressional Debate CD is individual debate in a large-group setting. Each tournament publishes a packet of legislation. Students role play as members of Congress and debate the aff/neg of the bills while following parliamentary procedure. |
Speeches are 3 min. each (w/ 15 sec. grace) 2 min. of questioning after the very first speaker on the topic; 1 min. of questioning per speaker after that. Each “session” will last 2-3 hours. |
|
|
Public Forum Debate PF is 2 vs. 2 debate around a resolution that changes each month, generally a controversial issue. Each round begins with a flip of a coin; the winner chooses either pro/con or 1st/2nd speaker. |
Speaker 1: 4 min. Speaker 2: 4 min. Crossfire (1 & 2): 3 min. Speaker 3: 4 min. Speaker 4: 4 min. Crossfire (3 & 4): 3 min. Speaker 1 Summary: 3 min. Speaker 2 Summary: 3 min. Grand Crossfire (all): 3 min. Speaker 3 Summary: 2 min. Speaker 4 Summary: 2 min. Each team gets up to 3 min. of prep time; Crossfire: questions asked by both sides, alternating, person who did not just speak has first question |
|
|
Lincoln-Douglas Debate LD is 1 vs. 1 debate around a resolution that changes each month, generally a philosophical / moral issue. Students debate both the aff/neg of the resolution, predetermined at the start of the round. |
Aff: 6 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Neg: 7 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Aff: 4 min. Neg: 6 min. Aff: 3 min. Each person gets up to 4 min. of prep time Cross-Ex: questions only asked by person who did not just speak |
|
|
Policy Debate CX is 2 vs. 2 debate around a resolution that calls for policy change by the U.S. government. The affirmative will present a plan, and the negative will either negate the resolution itself, negate the affirmative’s plan, or offer a counterplan (competing plan). |
Aff: 8 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Neg: 8 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Aff: 8 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Neg: 8 min. Cross-Ex: 3 min. Neg: 5 min. Aff: 5 min. Neg: 5 min. Aff: 5 min. Each team gets up to 8 min. of prep time Cross-Ex: questions only asked by team who did not just speak |
|