Polygon Invitational
2019
—
Washington HS, Fremont,
CA/US
Novice Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Saurabh Bhartia
Irvington HS
None
Last changed on
Wed September 16, 2020 at 12:10 PM PDT
I am a parent and have recently started judging(only since this year).
I want contestants to be courteous and respectable. Its ok to be aggressive but not rude.
I want both sides to present with clear arguments with valid supporting evidence. Keep it simple. If I don't understand the argument, it will become hard to me to vote for it. Explain everything thoroughly and focus more on content and evidence.
i dont usually disclose the results immediately
Have fun at your rounds!
Laura Crosby
Campolindo HS
None
Cathy Goldberg
Menlo-Atherton High School
Last changed on
Fri October 18, 2019 at 11:28 AM PDT
I am a parent judge with no debate experience. Please be organized in your presentation and avoid spreading. My daughter has explained the basic rules to me such as POIs and POOs.
I look forward to hearing all of your presentations.
Annie He
Irvington HS
None
Jessica Jatiram
Washington High School
Last changed on
Sat October 19, 2019 at 2:18 AM PDT
Don't be dumb. Terminalize your impacts. Remember net benefits.
Cheryl Kuo
Valley Christian High School
None
Rickard Loftman
Menlo-Atherton High School
None
Pranit Panda
Washington High School
8 rounds
Last changed on
Sat October 19, 2019 at 5:30 AM PDT
I DO NOT judge tabula rasa if your arguments are dumb, I'm not buying them and you lose.
Humor is one of the most important things I look for. If you make me laugh it will help you.
The louder you talk the better. If you shout your entire speech it's a huge positive.
Plans to resist the oppression of the bourgeoisie will be appreciated.
Shilpa Parikh
Menlo-Atherton High School
Last changed on
Thu January 21, 2021 at 6:51 AM EDT
Parent Judge.
I have judged at many middle school tournaments and high school tournaments including JV and Varsity but explain your contentions.
Do not spread. If you do, I will most likely stop writing on my paper and give you an auto-loss.
I like to evaluate on your method of weighing and your ability to provide reasonable arguments with support. Lots of debaters use net benefits, but if you want to use something different go ahead! Just make sure arguments actually tie to it.
Otherwise, have fun!
Emma Rheams
Valley Christian High School
8 rounds
None
Sam Saliba
Mentoring Academy
None
Hayagreev Sarvabhouman
Campolindo HS
8 rounds
None
Priya Sethuraman
Irvington HS
None
Ayush Shah
Washington High School
8 rounds
Last changed on
Sat October 19, 2019 at 2:30 AM PDT
I judge equally and fairly. I know all debate technicalities as I debated in the pro circuit. Do not use complicated words such as climate change and feminism without proper explanation. Remember that personal experiences may not be indicative what actually happens most of the time.
Liang Wang
Irvington HS
None
Last changed on
Sun April 3, 2022 at 4:28 PM PDT
I am a parent judge who has been judging in Parliamentary Debate for three years. During the round, make sure to clarify any terminologies or debate jargon that is utilized, and I generally enjoy arguments that are well supported with reasoning and logic alongside evidence to back it up. Make sure to also address all arguments made by your opponents during the round, and don't forget to weigh in the last speech. I am also not a fan of spreading as that often causes the debate to become messy and inaccessible.
Case debates are strongly preferred, but if technical arguments must be made, please explain them clearly. Only utilize Theory if it is against a problematic or abusive argument (I will not vote for frivolous theory), and I am also unfamiliar with kritiks.
Remember to respect one another and have fun!
Jerry Yang
Campolindo HS
None