2nd CUNY Debating Championships

2016 — New York, NY/US

Final Places in APDA

Place Name School/Team Ballots
1st (GU/GW Best Schemes) Bowles & Kishore GW 1 W 2 1 26.5 25.75
2 L 4 2 26.5 26.25
3 W 1 2 26.25 26.5
4 W 1 2 25.75 26
5 W 1 2 26.25 26.5
8 W W W
9 W W W
10 W W L
2nd (Columbia University in the City of New York II) Irani & Ivashkiv Columbia University in the City of New York 1 W 1 3 25.25 25.75
2 W 1 2 26.5 26.5
3 W 2 1 26.5 26.25
4 W 1 3 26.5 26
5 W 3 1 26.25 26
8 W L W
9 L W W
10 L L W
S (Young Scrappy and Hungry) Hamilton & Ashe Chicago 1 W 1 2 25.5 25.75
2 W 3 1 26.5 26.25
3 W 4 1 26.5 26
4 L 2 4 26.25 25.75
5 W 1 2 26 26.75
8 L W W
9 L L L
S (Virginia FM) Fidler & Moats Virginia 1 W 2 1 26 26
2 W 1 2 26.25 26.25
3 L 3 2 26.25 26.25
4 W 1 2 26 26.25
5 W 2 1 26.25 26.25
8 W L W
9 W L L
Q (AU (Type) A) Morgan & Orrico American Univeristy 1 W 2 1 26.25 26
2 W 1 2 26.25 26.5
3 W 1 2 26.5 26.5
4 W 2 1 26.5 26
5 W 1 2 27 26.5
8 W L L
Q (GW Efficient Market Hypothesis) Hess & Venkatasubramanian GW 1 W 2 1 26.5 26
2 W 1 2 26.25 26.25
3 L 3 4 26 26
4 W 1 2 26 26
5 W 2 1 26.5 26.75
8 L W L
Q (GW Sound Cage) Melniker & Whitehurst GW 1 W 1 2 26.5 26.5
2 W 2 1 26 26
3 W 1 2 26.5 26.75
4 W 1 2 26.25 26.5
5 L 2 4 26 26
8 L L L
Q (Columbia/Penn Clinton/Johnson 2016) Johnson & Song Pennsylvania 1 W 1 3 26.5 26.25
2 W 2 1 26.5 26.5
3 W 1 2 26 26.25
4 W 1 4 26.5 25.75
5 W 1 2 26.5 26.5
8 L W L
NS (UChicago SG) Schmerling & Gelfer Chicago 1 L 4 2 26.25 26
2 W 1 2 26 25.5
3 L 2 4 24.75 25.25
4 W 1 3 24 25.5
5 W 3 1 26.25 26
6 W
NS (UChicago ES) Ezra & Soodak Chicago 1 L 4 3 25.75 25.5
2 W 1 2 25.25 25.25
3 W 2 1 25.5 25
4 L 3 4 25.5 25.75
5 W 1 2 26.25 26
6 W
NS (Penn VR) Valliyur & Rajagopal Pennsylvania 1 L 3 4 25.5 25.25
2 W 1 3 25.25 26.25
3 L 3 4 24.5 24
4 W 1 3 26.5 26.5
5 W 2 3 26.2 26.1
6 L
NS (GU/Columbia Virtue Ethics) Driscoll & Ross Columbia University in the City of New York 1 W 2 1 25.75 25.5
2 W 3 1 26.25 25.75
3 W 1 2 26.5 26
4 L 4 3 26.25 26
5 L 3 4 26 25.5
6 L

Place Name School/Team Win Pts Rk Pts -1HL Rk -1HL H2H Pts -2HL Rk -2HL OSd Rand Ballots
Prelim (GU CC I) Clancy & Cohen Georgetown 4 260.5 19 156.5 14 0 52.25 11 16.75 4.32 1 W 1 2 26.25 26
2 L 3 4 26.25 26.25
3 W 1 2 26 25.75
4 W 2 1 26.5 26.25
5 W 2 1 25.75 25.5
Prelim (GW Blazin' and Nervous) Cryer & Matin GW 4 258.25 21 156.75 16 0 52.25 11 24.75 6.15 1 W 2 3 24.25 25
2 W 1 2 26 26.25
3 W 2 1 26 26.25
4 W 2 1 26 26.25
5 L 4 3 26.25 26
Prelim (UChicago 0-5) Liu & Kurila Chicago 3 260.5 27 156.25 22 0 52 17 15.8 0.11 1 W 3 2 26.25 26.25
2 W 1 3 25.75 25.5
3 L 4 3 26.5 26.5
4 W 3 1 26 25.75
5 L 4 3 26 26
Prelim (GW GBS) Gaby-Biegel & Sumimoto GW 3 260.25 21 156.5 16 0 52.25 13 19.66 1.47 1 W 2 1 25.75 25.5
2 L 3 2 26 26.25
3 W 2 1 26 26.25
4 W 1 2 26.25 26.25
5 L 3 4 26 26
Prelim (GW Indistinguishable From the Territory Which it Covered) Kelly & Shelton-Thomas GW 3 259.25 21 156 16 0 52 13 16.6 5.14 1 W 2 1 25 25.5
2 W 2 1 26.25 26.5
3 W 1 2 26 26
4 L 3 2 26 26.25
5 L 4 3 25.75 26
Prelim (Johns Hopkins LX) Li & Xiong Johns Hopkins 3 259.25 23 156 18 0 52 15 21.4 9.37 1 W 2 1 26.25 26
2 L 2 4 25.75 25.25
3 W 1 2 26 25.75
4 W 1 3 26.25 25.75
5 L 3 4 26.25 26
Prelim (Penn KT) Kern & Tagore Pennsylvania 3 259 22 155.25 17 0 51.5 12 22 7.25 1 L 2 3 26.25 26.25
2 W 2 1 25.5 25.75
3 W 1 2 25.75 25.75
4 W 3 1 26.5 26.25
5 L 3 4 25.5 25.5
Prelim (GW Himalayan Pink Rock Salt) Kane & Kim GW 3 257 22 153.5 17 0 51.25 11 29.75 3.58 1 L 4 2 25 25.5
2 L 3 2 25.5 25.25
3 W 2 1 25.5 26
4 W 3 1 25.75 25.5
5 W 1 3 26.5 26.5
Prelim (TCNJ/Lehighbrid) Guenther & Ganem Lehigh 3 255.25 26 154 21 0 51 16 16 1.78 1 L 4 1 26.5 25.75
2 W 1 3 25.25 25.75
3 W 4 1 25 24
4 L 3 4 25.25 25.5
5 W 4 1 26.25 26
Prelim (Penn BM) Brown & Moon Pennsylvania 3 254.06 25 154.31 20 0 50.81 14 22.33 9.36 1 L 2 4 24 23.5
2 B
3 L 3 4 25.75 26
4 W 3 1 26 25.75
5 W 1 2 26 26.25
Prelim (AU BK) Book & Klipstein American Univeristy 3 253.75 24 152.75 19 0 51.25 12 25 3.45 1 L 4 3 24 24.75
2 L 2 4 24.5 25.5
3 W 2 1 25.75 25.5
4 W 4 1 25.5 26
5 W 2 1 26 26.25
Prelim (UChicago Blacc Chyna) Gibbs & Kao Chicago 3 253.5 26 152.25 21 0 50.75 17 25.4 4.88 1 W 2.5 1.5 25 24.5
2 L 4 3 25 25
3 L 3 4 25.25 25.5
4 W 1 3 25.75 26
5 W 3 1 25.5 26
Prelim (Fordham SG) Shehu & Grewal Fordham 3 252.81 28.75 151.81 23.75 0 50.56 16.75 29 4.77 1 B
2 L 4 3 25 25
3 L 3 4 25.25 25.75
4 W 1 3 25.25 25.75
5 W 1 4 25.75 24.5
Prelim (UChicago Mango Smoothies) Loke & Ram Chicago 2 259.5 29 156 24 0 52.25 21 17 1.39 1 W 2 1 26.25 26
2 W 4 1 26.25 26
3 L 4 3 26 26.25
4 L 3 4 25.75 25.5
5 L 3 4 25.75 25.75
Prelim (GU Drink & Fight) Carabbio & Wang Georgetown 2 258 27 155 22 0 51.5 17 22 9 1 W 1 4 26 26.5
2 W 2 1 26.25 26
3 L 3 4 25 25.5
4 L 2 4 25.75 25.75
5 L 2 4 25.5 25.75
Prelim (Columbia University in the City of New York BM) Bogomolova & Melkonyan Columbia University in the City of New York 2 257.75 27 155 22 0 51.75 15 21.25 6.37 1 L 4 3 25.75 25.75
2 W 1 3 25.75 26
3 W 2 1 25.75 26
4 L 4 2 26.25 25.75
5 L 3 4 25.25 25.5
Prelim (UChicago SO) Saroyan & Openheimer Chicago 2 257.25 24 154.5 19 0 51.5 16 24.6 2.31 1 W 2 1 25.75 26
2 L 4 2 25.25 26
3 W 2 1 25.75 25.75
4 L 3 4 25.25 25.25
5 L 3 2 26 26.25
Prelim (TCNJ Rishabh) Akkaraju & Ganapa College of New Jersey 2 257.25 27 154.5 22 0 51.5 18 16.6 6.85 1 W 1 3 25.75 26
2 W 2 1 25.5 25.75
3 L 4 3 25.5 25.5
4 L 3 4 25.75 25.75
5 L 4 2 25.75 26
Prelim (Johns Hopkins GY) Gupta & Yuan Johns Hopkins 2 256.75 25 154.25 20 0 51.5 14 33.6 1.48 1 L 4 2 25.5 26
2 W 1 2 24.5 25
3 L 3 4 25.5 25.75
4 L 2 4 26 25.5
5 W 1 2 26.25 26.75
Prelim (UChicago ZS) Zakharov & Suri Chicago 2 256.4 25 154.4 20 0 51.5 13 34.75 2.95 1 L 3 4 24.75 25
2 L 4 3 25.5 25.25
3 W 2 1 25.75 25.75
4 W 1 2 26.25 26
5 L 4 1 26.4 25.75
Prelim (Maryland Team Lazarus) Baccus & Schreiber Maryland 2 256.25 25 154 20 0 51.25 17 23 4.87 1 W 2 1 25.75 25.25
2 L 3 4 25.5 25.75
3 W 1 3 26 26.25
4 L 2 4 25.75 26
5 L 2 3 25.25 24.75
Prelim (UChicago Rice & Nice) Breda & Wiltzer Chicago 2 256 26 153.75 21 0 51.25 18 17.75 3.32 1 W 2 1 25.5 25.75
2 L 3 4 25 25.75
3 L 3 4 26 25.75
4 W 2 1 25 25.5
5 L 4 2 26.5 25.25
Prelim (NYU Sucrose Daddy) Kang & Perkins N.Y.U 2 256 27 154 22 0 51.5 19 20.8 4.87 1 W 1 2 25.5 26
2 W 1 2 25 25.25
3 L 4 3 25.5 26
4 L 3 4 25.75 26
5 L 3 4 25.25 25.75
Prelim (Columbia University in the City of New York SE) Skidan & Eppolito Columbia University in the City of New York 2 256 27 153.75 22 0 51.25 15 29.2 2.15 1 L 4 3 25 25.5
2 W 4 1 25.75 25.25
3 L 4 2 26 25.75
4 L 2 4 25.5 26
5 W 1 2 25.5 25.75
Prelim (GU Lively From NY) Levy & Soderholm Georgetown 2 255 26.25 153 21.25 0 51 14.25 37 7.44 1 L 3 4 25.25 25.5
2 L 4 2 25.5 25.75
3 W 1 2 25.25 25.5
4 L 3 2 25.75 25.5
5 B
Prelim (Columbia University in the City of New York CH) Caraccio & Healy Columbia University in the City of New York 2 254.5 27 152.5 22 0 51 15 33.6 9.59 1 L 4 3 25.75 25.25
2 L 4 3 25.5 25.75
3 W 1 3 25.75 26
4 L 4 2 25 25.25
5 W 2 1 25.25 25
Prelim (Columbia University in the City of New York EN) Esteve & Nicenko Columbia University in the City of New York 2 254.25 26 153.25 21 0 51.25 16 29.6 6.93 1 L 2 3 24.5 24.75
2 W 3 1 25.75 25.5
3 L 3 4 25.5 25.25
4 L 3 4 25.75 26
5 W 1 2 25.5 25.75
Prelim (AU/UVA Hybrid) Nilov & Han American Univeristy 1 252 29 151.25 24 0 50.5 17 26.75 2.18 1 L 4 3 25 25
2 L 2 4 24.75 26
3 L 3 2 25 24.75
4 W 3 1 26 25
5 L 3 4 25.25 25.25
Prelim (UChicago SB) Stein & Broshy Chicago 1 251.25 30 151 25 0 50.25 21 31.5 8.64 1 W 3 1 25 24.5
2 L 4 3 25.25 25.5
3 L 2 4 25 25.75
4 L 4 2 25.25 24.75
5 L 4 3 25.25 25
Prelim (TCNJ Viable Third Party) Jones & Armstrong College of New Jersey 1 250 32.5 151 26.5 0 50 19.5 25 4.74 1 L 4 3 24 24
2 L 4 3 24.75 25.25
3 L 4 2 25.75 25.25
4 L 4 2 24.5 26.5
5 B
Prelim (Southern Methodist HB) Hebron & Butt Southern Methodist 1 245.31 33.75 147.31 27.75 0 49.06 21.75 33.75 1.02 1 L 2 4 24.5 24.75
2 L 4 3 24.25 24.5
3 L 3 4 24.5 24.75
4 B
5 L 3 4 24.5 24.5
Prelim (Princeton LH) Hu & Le Princeton 1 245.1 23 193.1 18 0 91.85 15 32.25 1.88 1 W 2 1 25.75 26
2 L 3 4 24.5 25
3 L 4 3 25.5 25.5
4 L 4 2 26.5 25.5
5 0 0
Prelim (Fordham YA) Yao & Alvarez Fordham 1 240.62 33.75 144.12 27.75 0 48.12 20.75 23.75 7.43 1 L 3 4 24.75 24.25
2 L 3 4 24 23.5
3 B
4 L 4 2 24 23.5
5 L 4 3 24.5 24
Prelim (Johns Hopkins DJ) Drukker-Schardl & Judd Johns Hopkins 1 240 25 189 20 0 89.5 13 24.2 7.81 1 L 3 4 24.5 24.75
2 L 4 3 25 24.5
3 W 1 4 25.5 24.75
4 L 4 2 25.25 25.75
5 0 0
Prelim (Dionysus is better than Apollo) Metz-Lerman & Mhaidli Grinnell Debating Union 1 237.3 23 186.8 18 0 88.3 11 30 7.63 1 L 4 3 25 25.5
2 L 3 2 24.5 24.25
3 L 3 4 24 24
4 W 1 3 25.5 25
5 0 0