El Dorado NoviceJV

2017 — El Dorado, KS/US

Crystal Crank Paradigm

Not Submitted

Makayla Dashner Paradigm

Not Submitted

Baine Dikeman Paradigm

On Topicality- It is a fine argument for negative strategy and is one I would vote on it.

On Counterplans- These are also fine, but the net benefit must be strong. I would also like to see how the CP is better based on the Aff's solvency.

On Kritiks- Not a huge fan because they are not explained well typically. It is not something I would typically vote on, unless the alternative is good enough and the Neg fully understands what they are running.

Generics are fine, so long as there is a solid analytic to link.

On speed- Spreading is fine, however, I would appreciate it if the tag lines to cards were slowed and articulated well- thanks.

If theory and framework are stated in the round, I will more than likely follow that framework. So, both teams need to address those topics. It is not my favorite thing to judge, but if it is brought up, I will follow it.

If the debaters have any questions about the paradigm before the round, they are free to ask.

Makenna Hayes Paradigm

Not Submitted

Cyla Hoefgen Paradigm

Not Submitted

Pricillia Kralicek Paradigm

Not Submitted

Madison Lopez Paradigm

Not Submitted

Michelle McCoy Paradigm

Not Submitted

Catherine Mitchell Paradigm

Not Submitted

Blake Overman Paradigm

Not Submitted

Scott Roberts Paradigm

Not Submitted

Logan Stenseng Paradigm

Not Submitted

Catherine Todd Paradigm

Not Submitted

Ashley Tolle Paradigm

Not Submitted

Thaddus Tuck Paradigm

Not Submitted

Thomas Tuck Paradigm

Not Submitted

Nelson Warren Paradigm

Not Submitted

Kenzie Watson Paradigm

Not Submitted

Metti Wright Paradigm

Not Submitted