The Harvard Westlake Debates
2018 — Los Angeles, CA/US
MSPDP Motions/Schedule & Information
Teams should be prepared to debate both of these topics on each side.
Rounds 1 & 2:
In the United States, voting should be compulsory.
Rounds 3 & 4:
In the face of injustice, civil disobedience is morally required.
Prep Time:
1. Per MSPDP guidelines, electronic devices (i.e tablets and laptops) are now allowed during prep time. Cases do not need to be printed.
2. Teams will prep for both Rounds 1 & 2 BEFORE round 1
Format & Entry:
We will use the standard MSPDP format of 5 minute constructives and a 5 minute rebuttal.
Each school will be allowed to enter 4 teams. Please enter any additional teams onto the waiting list. Teams will be allowed to debate and earn wins as teams of two. However, since the activity is a 3-person activity, awards will be limited to teams with three members who participate in all rounds. We find that sometimes teams take advantage of the loophole of allowing 2-person teams because it might be strategic to keep a weaker (3rd) person off a team. All debaters will still be eligible for speaker awards.
Entry Fees: $55.00 to cover the cost of the food for the team, judges and awards.
Judge Requirement: Schools must bring 1 judge available to actually judge (not be trained) in every round, for every two teams.
Here is a grid to help:
1 team - 1 judge available every round
2 teams - 1 judge available every round
3 teams - 2 judges available every round
4 teams - 2 judges available every round
5 teams - 3 judges available every round
… and so on.
Tentative Schedule
8:00am - Coaches should arrive to let us know their entire teams are there and to confirm judges. At this point we will also give schools their assigned rooms.
8:40am - Announce the topic/pairing for the first two rounds.
9:00am - Round 1
10:30am - release pairing for Round 2
10:50am - Round 2
12:00pm - Lunch
12:40pm - Announce the topic/pairing for the second two rounds
1:00pm - Round 3
2:15pm - release pairing for Round 4
2:30pm - Round 4
4:00pm - Awards