Jacqueline Wei Paradigm

Last changed 7/25 11:10A CDT

I competed in PF and Extemp for Plano West and graduated in 2019.

Please preflow!

If you don’t paraphrase and read all cut cards in case, tell me and I will give both speakers +1 speaks. Paraphrasing in rebuttal is fine (unless you misconstrue the evidence!)

With regards to the new 3 minute summary: Please still collapse--use that minute for in-depth argumentation and weighing instead of going for everything on the flow.

Important Stuff:

  1. Speaking fast is fine, full on double breath spreading is a no
  2. Defense from 1st rebuttal sticks in 1st summary unless 2nd rebuttal has responded to it.
  3. No independent unrelated contentions in rebuttal--DAs that are related to your opponent's contentions are fine.
  4. I prefer all weighing to be set up in summary at the latest (there's 3 minutes now, use the extra minute for weighing). If you'd like to set up weighing before that, go for it. I will not evaluate new weighing in final focus unless it is the only way to resolve the round.
  5. I do not strictly require 2nd rebuttal to respond to offense or defense from 1st rebuttal; however, I think it is extremely strategic to respond to at least offense from 1st rebuttal in most, if not all, cases.
  6. carded warrant > uncarded warrant > carded unwarranted empirics. “This is unwarranted” is an acceptable response. Don’t card dump.
  7. I am unwilling to evaluate new arguments in 2nd final focus. If your delink suddenly becomes a turn, or your impact suddenly becomes a million times bigger, or your link suddenly has a new "nuance" in 2nd final focus, I will drop the entire argument, so you might as well just keep the original argument.
  8. I do not think frontlines are sufficient to serve as case extensions. You should extend not only your entire link chain + impact but also the warrants as to why your links/impacts are true.
  9. If you don't weigh, I will intervene with a common-sense weighing mechanism (probability or magnitude). I will not presume neg unless there is zero offense in the round.
  10. I won't vote for disclosure theory.

Speaks: 27 - 30 unless you are rude, condescending, racist, sexist, homophobic, etc.

Ev: I will call for ev if it’s important in the round AND either 1) anyone tells me to call for it or 2) I think it might be misconstrued based on previous knowledge. I know that as the round progresses sometimes cards get power tagged accidentally, and that’s fine, but if you straight up clip your cards or misconstrue them heavily I’ll dock your speaks and also possibly drop you.

Theory: Don’t really know the tech side of theory and also really REALLY hate the trend of some teams running theory to confuse opponents instead of actually checking back abuse. If you want to check back abuse just explain the abuse and why I should drop the arg/debater intuitively.

If you have any questions, ask before round.

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Harvard APDA Tournament 10/11/2019 R5 NYU GL BroDeb TW Neg
Harvard APDA Tournament 10/11/2019 R4 Columb GG Prince CW Aff
Harvard APDA Tournament 10/11/2019 R3 Yale CW Bates BP Aff
Harvard APDA Tournament 10/11/2019 R2 Penn PK Columb SA Neg
Harvard APDA Tournament 10/11/2019 R1 BroDeb MuSt Yale ScSu Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R11 Shankar Cohort Huang & Chasse Ferguson Cohort Luo & Dintzner Neg Aff on a 4-3
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R9 Summit PSC Rock & Singer Summit SJS Yi & Nie Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R8 Forum SKS Workhlu & Bommineni Forum MCP Mishra & Yuan Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R8 Forum SCM Wang & Pattipati Forum MPK Kinzfogl & Bauer Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R7 Cigale Cohort Wen & Hu Feng Cohort Yu & Li Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R7 Lin/Wei Cohort Ma & Ye Hazeldine Cohort Harris & Wang Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R6 Gregory Cohen & Sean Behling Cooper Carlile & Christian Weiland-Santiago Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R6 Sridhar Cohort Dubey & Fiorito Feng Cohort Yang & Syed Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R6 Shankar Cohort Huang & Chasse Jiang Cohort Xu & Dong Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R6 Apex MMF Verska & Sjostrom Summit PSC Akbar & Mapa Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R6 Erin Cunningham & Mariam Khamaj Maddie Pekarek & Hannah Sweet Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R5 Joshua Knight & Davis Abrams Adam Hassan & Michael Behling Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R5 Summit SDS Mckenzie & Doerr Forum MCW Moon & Sheyman Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R5 Feng Cohort Gowda & Biswas Sridhar Cohort Dandi & Sylvester Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R5 Theo Datta & Jasper Datta Daniel Liu & Andrew Pan Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R5 Ferguson Cohort Menendez & Schendel Motolinia Cohort Goldstone & Zhang Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R4 Forum PSF Goodwin & Morris Forum MPK Keskinyan & Patel Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R4 Forum YEJ Yang & Syed Forum MPK Song & Ramabhadran Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Symposium CCW Roy & Sidhu Symposium HWC Chung & Li Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Vasquez/Gill Cohort Zhao & Hu Feng Cohort Yang & Syed Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Shankar Cohort Boone & Yin Ferguson Cohort Menendez & Schendel Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Hazeldine Cohort Chang & Zhu Ferguson Cohort Luo & Dintzner Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Summit CAC Choudhury & Lu Summit AKS Pamidmukkala & Baisinger-Rosen Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R3 Samrat Pradhan & Skylar Wang Jane Grey Battle & Caroline Allen Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R2 Olivia Li & Arianna Roberts Anirudh Nistala & Sarah Jeddy Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R2 Apex MMF Razzak & Bhagavatula Apex FMJ Marsh & Bilson Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R2 Colin Wei & Daniel Li Aanan Biswas & Rishi Gowda Aff
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Kushal Mishra & Jerry Yuan Arya Mirza & Abigail Shilts Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Apex BWW Alamy & Gumlia Apex BWW Jaisinghani & Balaje Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Shankar Cohort Jiang & Qian Motolinia Cohort Goldstone & Zhang Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Zhuoran Wen & Joshua King Clara Leach & Gavin Enseleit Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Lin/Wei Cohort Yu & Ramabhadran Motolinia Cohort Li & Nachuri Neg
NDF Boston Intensive 7/13/2019 PF R1 Apex BWW Chapple & Yu Apex BWW Kalra & Menendez Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R9 Summit BSW Shakir & Panda Summit BSW Lee & Krishnan Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF Quarte Sreeram Satish & Hrishi Marakani Arjun Singh & Calvin Xie Neg Neg on a 3-0
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF Octos Vicky Bai & Rhea Jain Jack Chang & Kylie Chang Neg Aff on a 2-1
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R8 Summit MMF Sarwar & Desai Forum FJW Han & McKenna Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R8 Forum SCS Kc & Lee Summit BSW Singh & Xie Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R7 Forum CMW Iyyavoo & Kanukuntla Forum FJW Sanyal & Burke Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R7 Symposium OBL Chan & Chao Symposium OBL Lee & Lin Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R7 Abhiram Annaluru & Vincent Zhi Tom Inouye & Abigail Wallach Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R6 Prahan Poreddy & Matthew Day Mandy Li & Abhinav Palivela Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R5 Forum SCS Mishra & Dinesh Forum FVH Xu & Bastani Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R5 Tannvi Banerjee & James Paine Aaryan Mukherjee & Sonia Nihalani Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R5 Summit MMF Groman & Nair Forum SCS Moffatt & Hossain Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R4 Forum CMW Ke & Wong Symposium OBL Kao & Cai Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R4 Advaith Anakala & Akhil Vinjamaram Manvitha Pabbathi & Niani Panjwani Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R3 Jamie Tan & Tiya Jain Pranav Saravanan & Mateen Sekandari Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R3 Forum FVH Chang & Chang Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R2 Tienming Shao & Chinyoung Shao Victor Xie & Jack Williams Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R2 Summit BSW Park & Kim Summit BSW Shakir & Panda Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R2 Aidan Wong & Jeffrey Ke Sreeram Satish & Hrishi Marakani Neg
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 LD R1 Nicole Williams Darsh Gupta Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R1 Summit BSW Bridgwaters & Stern Summit BSW Slovin & Mostow Aff
NDF San Jose 6/28/2019 PF R1 Summit BSW Gladson & Busby Summit BSW Park & Kim Neg