Madison White Paradigm

Last changed 15 June 2021 10:53 PM PDT

Hello lil baby debaters !!!!

heres the gist of it... I did policy debate at Bentonville High School for 3yrs..

I will easily be able to follow your arguments and your speed... but if your spreading is UNCLEAR then it won't make it onto my flow.

-- ORGANIZATION IS KEY!!!! If you don't sign post I won't know where arguments go. I'm a flow judge and if I don't know where your argument goes then it will probably hinder how I evaluate the round at the end

-- if you want outstanding speaker points you have to work for it... just because you can spread isn't enough for me, you have to be able to show me that you can speak PERSUASIVELY!! Slow down, emphasize words, repetition, hand gestures, analogies, eye contact. I should be completely moved to tears/ action by your speech.

-- NEVER END A SPEECH BEFORE THE TIMER GOES OFF. you should always have something to say

-- don't ask if you can sit during your speech the answer is no-- **THIS WAS PRECOVID U CAN SIT**

______________________

-- I will flow any argument but you better KNOW it and be able to explain it well. If you are going to read something that you just found a few hrs before... be careful

-- if it comes down to a specific card I will comb through it so this is a WARNING to make sure your card says EXACTLY what you are arguing .... I would rather you have incredibly strong analytics than mediocre evidence

-- if you have strong evidence/ can argue something crazy really well, then go for it. my outside biases/ opinions do not affect my view. You have good evidence that says Atlantis the lost city has been found then it's a valid argument that must be adequately addressed by your opponent. Argue that your team is actually pirates idc

____________________

-- rebuttals need impact calc.

-- I like rebuttals to consist of analysis of the round, less cards & more explaining WHY your team is winning

-- TOPICALITY IS A PRIORI (I don't care what the new fad is, but to me that is one of the most important things in the round) --> that also means, don't run dumb ones and make sure your technique is correct

_______________________

-- NEG try not to bring up new arguments in the 2nc... it annoys me when rebuttals turn into the aff whining/ a debate over the rules of policy. If you DO bring up a new argument it better be the strongest thing you have, don't just waste time.

-- NEG I want to see a good use of the negblock... don't say the exact same thing for 13 mins

-- I WANT CLASH. Case debate is so often swept under the rug !!!! even if you don't have specific cards against their case I will flow analytics. Strong analytics !!!!!!! This holds true for all forms of debate.

________________________

-- don't be rude to your opponents during cross ex

-- don't run sexist, racist, homophobic, etc.. arguments. If I think that the round has become offensive I will stop you and force you to take YOUR prep time to re evaluate. Don't be insensitive.

-- if you flash files I will not count it as prep

-- have a phone or timer for your speech... I will not be your judge AND timekeeper.

-- open cross ex is fine in my book BUT if your partner is answering all the questions for you I will take that to mean that you don't understand what you just read

-- do NOT start off cross ex with 'how are you' or lame filler questions. Just end cross ex or ask for more details... but don't waste my time. CROSS EX SHOULD BE INTENTIONAL.

______________________

-- K affs are fun, go for it !!!

-- do not forget to extend your case in every speech.

--AFF if you are going to have framework in your plan I better hear it until the very end. Don't say read it in the 1ac and then not mention it again until rebuttals.. I will consider it dropped

______________________

FOR PF and LD...

-- I've judged enough rounds that I understand and can follow the arguments you make

-- I'm okay with K's being run in an LD round but no CPs; progressive or traditional whatever your preference is go for it

-- I know that PF and LD are supposed to focus more heavily on slow, well spoken, persuasive speeches, that being said, I am okay with speed but DO NOT SPREAD.

-- look you don't get a lot of time in these speeches, I get that, but I also need to see that you are adequately responding to every argument on the flow !!! (This is part of being organized)

-- impact calc is still relevant, I wanna hear some hella persuasive speaking in those summary speeches

-- also you CAN debate the weighing criteron... I expect you to extend. Don't just define your criteron, you better put it into the context of the resolution.

-- no 'open cx' in pf, don't ask. You have grand crossfire/ you should know your case well enough to answer questions on your own.

_______________________

Big Questions

-- have fun... good luck... I better hear some enticing, impressive, creative, and logical arguments !!!! Claaaaaassssshhhhhh! Do your research.

- don't just repeat your case over and over...

________________________

Congress

- i don’t remember reading or even thinking about paradigms the few times I participated in Congress back in the old day BUT in case you are reading this… most of what i said for PF/LD apply to you. I would say be more cautious with speed because other judges aren’t gonna like that even though i don’t mind as long as you can talk fast and still be persuasive and include tone fluctuation

- when disagreeing (or agreeing) with an argument if u mention someone refer to them as a fellow delegate.

——————————————————-

-- if you decide to flash or have some sort of email chain during round I want to be included. whitemadisonj@gmail.com

-- I try not to disclose in round because I want you guys motivated and encouraged for your next round so PLEASE don't ask me who won

-- I expect you to come to the round having already read my paradigm... you may ask me questions about what I have said or anything I didn't specify but I will not repeat all of what I have typed

-- be unique and creative !!! Have fun with this !!!!! Can't wait to see how hard you have all worked !!

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 NIPDA Finals 10 Joshua Schmidt 10 Brayden Hartwig Neg Neg 3-0
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 VPF Finals 3 Amber Beard 10 Hill & Kirk Pro Pro 3-0
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 NPF Quarte 3 Adineh-Kharat & Morden 18 Rackley & Pineda Con
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 NLD R3 6 COLBY Crihfield 3 Bailey Van Neg
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 NLD R2 5 Andrew Rogers 3 Joelle Buckner Neg
ACTAA High School December Regional HS 2020-11-28 NLD R1 3 Isabella Parker 2 Isabella Moody Aff
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 VLD Semis 7 Matthew Eddy 17 Malachi Terry Aff Aff 2-1
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 VLD Quarte 11 Sara Hardin 3 Alexis Childs Neg
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 VPF Parial 3 Lester & Farris 6 English & Finkenbinder Con Con 3-0
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 NLD R3 3 Annabelle Morden 17 Ashley Garcia Aff
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 NLD R2 7 Coglin Deter 3 Jace Owens Neg
ACTAA High School October Regional HS 2020-10-17 NLD R1 17 Logan Bills 3 Haley Robbins Neg
ACTAA High School September Regional HS 2020-09-20 VPF Semis 2 Adams & Heath 1 Merrick & Saddler Con Con 3-0
ACTAA High School September Regional HS 2020-09-20 NLD R5 1 Kiya Massery 11 Samuel Carrero Neg
ACTAA High School September Regional HS 2020-09-20 NLD R4 1 Desiree Boykin 11 Dakota Young Neg
ACTAA High School September Regional HS 2020-09-20 NLD R2 1 Chloe Howard 7 William Causey Aff
ACTAA High School September Regional HS 2020-09-20 NLD R1 7 Arlis Sprinkle 1 Joelle Buckner Neg
1st and 2nd Year National Championships at Woodward Academy HS 2018-03-23 CX1 R5 Georgetown Day DelotVilain & Lundy Marist Ovadje & Feeney Neg
1st and 2nd Year National Championships at Woodward Academy HS 2018-03-23 CX1 R3 Jesuit CP Cribbins & Campbell Greenhill Feinstein & Kwon Neg
1st and 2nd Year National Championships at Woodward Academy HS 2018-03-23 CX1 R2 Niles West Bat-erdene & Kintner Chattahoochee Manne & Bryant Neg
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 NPF Finals 1 Cao & Ellis 9 Ruth & Vaughn Aff Aff 3-0
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 NLD Quarte 9 Joseph Wittig 8 Noelle Wright Neg
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 BQ R3 9 Josephine Pettway 8 Goodwin-Harrison & Smith Neg
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 BQ R3 9 Abigail Coe 8 Knauls & Wilson Neg
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 NCX R2 1 Marathe & Talluri 1 Corbett & Berry Aff
North Little Rock Wildcat Classic HS 2017-12-01 NCX R1 1 Duca & Ziegler 1 Pandey & Tavva Neg
Bentonville Wild West Invitational HS 2017-11-03 NPF Finals 6 Dranow & Van Hosen 4 Crow & Hearne Neg Neg 3-0
Bentonville Wild West Invitational HS 2017-11-03 NCX R3 1 Saravanan & Vinyard 1 Brandon & Watts Neg
Bentonville Wild West Invitational HS 2017-11-03 NCX R2 1 Harrell & Teague 1 Wiginton & Thurston Neg
Bentonville Wild West Invitational HS 2017-11-03 NCX R1 1 Hernandez & Snodgrass 1 Gjeruldsen & Gardner Neg
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ Finals Zander Arnao Lane & Camacho Aff Aff 2-1
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ Semis Josh Slocum Lane & Camacho Neg Neg 3-2
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ Quarte Douglas & Keogh Ohol & Van Slooten Neg Neg 2-1
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ R3 Pottridge & Brindle Thomas Guarino Aff
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ R2 Armstrong & Breckenridge Khemiri & Halle Neg
Bentonville Big Questions HS 2017-04-14 BQ R1 Wilkerson & Sisco Josh Slocum Neg