Luca White-Matthews Paradigm

Last changed 3 October 2020 9:05 AM PDT

I have been doing debate for over 8 years now and have debated in pretty much every format possible both in America and Canada. If you have specific questions that aren't covered here, ask me before hand.

TL:DR - I like quality debates that are built on good strategic decisions that are appropriate in the context of your format. I do not believe in replacing thorough and nuanced logic and explanations with jargon, even in the interest of efficiency. IF YOU HAVE ME AS A WSD JUDGE, THERE IS A SPECIFIC SECTION BELOW.

While I can keep up with pretty much anything you run, I will not do any work for you. If you are competing in an American debate format and are running something progressive, assuming its appropriate for your format, make sure you do everything you need to do to make it a convincing and mechanically complete argument. That includes explaining what you're running and why you're running it. While I likely have experience with the progressive arguments you are running, in the interest of judging tabula rasa, I will pretend I have none.

I can keep up with spreading but would prefer not too. If you are going to spread, flash me your case beforehand.

I have nearly zero tolerance for tactics and strategies that are exclusionary to your opponent and other debaters in general, especially when those tactics are used against newer debaters. I will not awards losses for this behavior because I realize it is somewhat subjective, but I will adjust speaker points.

WORLD SCHOOLS SPECIFIC INFO

WSD is not an American format and I have zero tolerance for debaters that treat it like one. Understand the different assumptions and rules that underpin WSD before debating in it and do not assume they are the same as American debate formats because they are not. While there are many differences, here are some key ones to keep in mind:

- No cards

- No technical jargon

- No progressive arguments

- No spreading

- Greater emphasis on rhetoric and logic

- Debates must focus on the core of the issue rather than niche arguments

- It is acceptable to drop arguments if they are no longer important. Dropped arguments do not immediately mean a team has won

- MOST IMPORTANTLY: WSD debates are focused on the entire world, or some reasonably large segment of it, rather than just America

With that being said, WSD is a growing format in the US and I understand and respect that. People will make mistakes and default to habits from American formats and that is okay as long as you are not intentionally trying to change the format by bringing in American debate strategies and rules.

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
National Debate Coaches Association National Championship HS 2021-04-10 WSD R6 Potomac ERE Greenhill SHLSY Prop
National Debate Coaches Association National Championship HS 2021-04-10 WSD R4 Dougherty Valley CMYSX Greenhill HSACM Prop
National Debate Coaches Association National Championship HS 2021-04-10 WSD R2 Harvard-Westlake MLDHM Greenhill KGSS Opp
Harvard College World Schools Invitational 2021 HS 2021-03-17 WSD R6 VDAVan Liu & Long & Zhang IvyPat Hu & Xu & Liao & Cao Opp
Harvard College World Schools Invitational 2021 HS 2021-03-17 WSD R5 VDAVan Zhang & Hwang & Chang & Wu & Wu ASFU Kim & Rebon & Kuss & Castroparedes & Villegas Opp
Harvard College World Schools Invitational 2021 MS 2021-03-17 WSD R3 GEEli Wu & Wang & Yin & Wang Dialog Baldwin Prop
Harvard College World Schools Invitational 2021 MS 2021-03-17 WSD R2 Impact Bobby & He & Qian & Sun & He IvyPlu Yi & Song & Wu & Zhang & Chen Opp
Harvard Westlake Debates HS 2021-01-14 WSD R5 Coppell VIDM Greenhill HSAMC Prop
Harvard Westlake Debates HS 2021-01-14 WSD R3 Valencia ADDD Greenhill SYHLS Opp
Harvard Westlake Debates HS 2021-01-14 WSD R1 NSDA Team USA LMPT West Windsor Plainsboro HS North SWCG Prop
Damus Hollywood Invitational HS 2020-11-07 WSD Rd3 Thunder Ridge GHR Blake Black Prop
Damus Hollywood Invitational HS 2020-11-07 WSD Rd1 Polytechnic TDZ Blake Blue Prop
Damien Chuck Ballingall Memorial Invitational Virtual Edition HS 2020-10-03 WSDC R2 Flintridge Prep Chong & Wilson & Pitney Notre Dame Francisco & Grau & Safar & Wilson Neg
Damien Chuck Ballingall Memorial Invitational Virtual Edition HS 2020-10-03 WSDC R1 Polytechnic Lazzi & Zhang & Ward Notre Dame Barry & Foti & Solamo Aff