Betty Fisher-Stanton Paradigm
Last changed 25 February 2021 7:18 AM CDT
LD: I'm a very traditional judge. I like values and criteria and analysis and clash. I don’t like Ks or anything based entirely on theory with no actual clash.
PF: I’m a very traditional judge. If the round becomes a very short CX round instead of a PF round, we have a problem. I want evidence and actual analysis of that evidence, and I want actual clash. Again, I don’t like Ks or anything based entirely on theory.
CX: I can handle your spread and I will vote where I'm persuasively told to with the following exceptions: 1) I have never voted on T. I think it's a non-starter. 2) I do not like Ks because I feel like there is always a performative contradiction. 3) I, again, will always prefer actual clash in the round over unlinked theory arguments.
Full Judging Record