Kylie Vera ParadigmLast changed 12/20 9:31P PDT
Please add me to the email chain: email@example.com
Saint George's Class of 2018
Whitworth University (Not Debating)
Please avoid mentions of sexual assault, suicide, and self-harm. Thank you.
First year out debate, got 2 bids 2 different years, a state finalist both my junior and senior year. I debated mostly critical arguments throughout high school but I also occasionally read topical affs and cut politics updates. I will vote based off of what is on the flow.
Tech > Truth
I don't read cards unless deemed necessary.
Despite my debate experience, I actually think framework is a good argument. I read framework against critical affs and enjoy listening to good framework rounds.
I'm less of a fan of the "t not framework" argument but can be persuaded otherwise.
I will vote on any standard if you win it. I tend to incline that fairness is more of an internal link, not an impact but if you win the flow I will vote for it.
I don't think fun is an impact and have a high threshold to vote on it if it is your 2NR strategy.
I think you must have a TVA, preferably with carded evidence to support it. I believe it should be gone for in the 2NR to make my decision easier. If one is impossible though, you need to spend a substantial time on SSD.
I default to competing interpretations unless told otherwise.
Slow down in the rebuttals so I can get all the nuances of your argument.
I don't like artificially competitive and contrived process counterplans. Otherwise, if you read any other counterplan and explains how it avoids the link to the DA I will vote for you.
I don't like PICS or contrived multiplank counterplans.
I don't really care if you read new planks on the 2NC but it does warrant new 1AR answers.
I think counterplans should have a solvency advocate that clearly describes the process of the CP.
I am very willing to pull the trigger on CP theory if explained and impacted out.
Love politics disads more than the average judge but I am willing to vote on any DA.
I love impact calc and please do it.
I will probably understand any critic if you explain it will but here are my current understandings
Very familiar with: Agamben, Irigaray, Baudrillard, Queer Theory, Afro-pessimism, Cybernetics, Setcol, Bifo, Marx, Security, and Bataille
Pretty familiar with: Fannon, Foucault, Psychoanalysis, Virilio, Deleuze, and Weheliye
Not super familiar with: Preciado, Negarestani, Maoism, and Derrida
I don't mind long overviews as long as they relate to the debate I'm judging.
PLEASE DO LINE BY LINE!
I won't vote on k tricks if they're not impacts and explained
I think Ks need a clear link to some part of the aff.
If the neg team kicks the alt they need to win a strong link and impact.
Read and am comfortable with every type of critical aff.
I think critical affs need to be related to the topic in some way.
When debating framework you should go for a counter interp strategy or an impact turn but not both. They can both be in the 2AC but not the 2AR.
I think you need to answer every impact of framework individually.
30: Gosh darn I'm telling everyone about you
29.5 - 29.9: You should be in the top 5 speakers
29 - 29.5: You should break
28.5 - 29: You're pretty good, good at line-by-line!
28 - 28.5: You're good but have some work to do
< 28: You were openly racist, sexist, homophobic, or rude
Aidan Kane, Wayne Tang, Sarah Roberts
Full Judging Record
|Gonzaga Debate Institute Tournament||1563969600 7/24/2019||OPEN||9 S||a SLacK in the face Charlie Huang & Aarin Jain||Liberal Brew Joshua Ramos & Jack Martin||Neg||Neg on a 3-0|
|Gonzaga Debate Institute Tournament||1563969600 7/24/2019||OPEN||7 O||Liberal Brew Joshua Ramos & Jack Martin||Biggie Molls Elizabeth Chen & Kelly Lin||Aff||Aff on a 3-0|
|Gonzaga Debate Institute Tournament||1563969600 7/24/2019||SCHLRS||6 R6||Scholars Jasper Toms & Virinch Pandari||Scholars Jared Adam & Nick Clancy||Neg|
|Gonzaga Debate Institute Tournament||1563969600 7/24/2019||OPEN||5 R5||Liberal Brew Alex Miller & Josh Miller||a SLacK in the face Charlie Huang & Aarin Jain||Neg|
|Saint Georges Invitational||1544225400 12/7/2018||OPol||7 Quarte||Kamiak DB||Garfield DL||Aff||Aff on a 3-0|
|Saint Georges Invitational||1544225400 12/7/2018||OPol||6 R6||Ingraham ST||Kamiak KE||Neg|
|Saint Georges Invitational||1544225400 12/7/2018||OPol||2 R2||Silver Creek RV||Kamiak KL||Neg|