Ashton Poindexter

  • Paradigm
  • Record
Paradigm Statement
Last changed 23 October 2021 5:09 AM MDT

Kritiks: I'm familiar with critical literature, but I want the alternative to be explained well because it creates better debate about the method of the alternative. If the kritik literature is not very well known you should create a thesis level argument to provide clarity about the kritik debate.

K Affs: Everything said on Kritiks applies here as well and you should also clearly explain why you reading a k aff is justified.

Theory/T: I think that theory is a legitimate check for abuse and prefer if you're running it strategically and not just as a timeskew. Make sure that your voters are terminalized, I don't want to just be told to "vote for education and fairness," tell me why those matter.

DA's: I'm not a huge fan of linear disadvantages but I will still vote for them. On Uniqueness I'm more likely to believe that uniqueness doesn't overwhelm the link if you give me a direction of the status quo instead of the status of it (For example, on an Econ DA it's better to say the economy is improving slowly rather than saying the economy is amazing).

Debate should be fun, don't be a dick.

Full Judging Record
Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Woods Cross Select Ugly Christmas Sweater Tournament HS 2019-12-13 CX R3 AP 504 AX 502 Neg
Woods Cross Select Ugly Christmas Sweater Tournament HS 2019-12-13 CX R2 BL 500 AP 501 Aff
Woods Cross Select Ugly Christmas Sweater Tournament HS 2019-12-13 CX R1 AX 500 AP 502 Aff
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 VPF R3 Skylin Cheatham & Burke RowHal Abdalla & Sheinberg Pro
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 VPF R3 WesJor Hughes & Ertman Skylin Ying & Chester Pro
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 VLD R2 Summit Omar Khan ParCit Aidin O'Brien Aff
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 VLD R2 Timpvi Lauren Jones WesJor Cody Sargent Neg
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 NPF R1 RowHal Bahna & green WesHS Bargeron & Sorensen Con
Skyhawk Smackdown HS 2018-11-16 NPF R1 RowHal Houden & Stevens Timpvi Fairbourne & Gallman Pro
Copper Classic HS 2018-01-12 OCX R6 Green Canyon AW Sky View PH Aff
Copper Classic HS 2018-01-12 OCX R4 Salem Hills AW Green Canyon YN Aff