Tina Moon-Lee Paradigm

Last changed 2/14 4:35P EDT

Although I “flow” arguments on a flow pad, please note that I am not a technical judge which provides points here and there and tries to determine which arguments were “carried” to the end of the round or which ones were “dropped”. Instead, I flow to help me keep track of the arguments that are made by both sides and the critical analysis that is conveyed to me to support or refute arguments. Please use the crossfires to ask each other questions and speak to each other, rather than addressing me and asking me to take note of certain statements (which can and should be done during summary and final focus). Consider the final focus as the points I should consider in my reason for judgement write up.

Please weigh, as I find this to be critical to my analysis.

Use "cards" only to support your analysis, not to say "my card is better than your card". A round that heavily relies on "card" after "card" has missed the mark of what debate is about.

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF Octos 4128 4140 Neg Neg on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF Play-I 4155 4019 Neg Neg on a 3-0
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R5 4122 4023 Aff Aff on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R5 4035 4183 Aff Aff on a 3-0
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R4 4111 4052 Neg Neg on a 3-0
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R4 4066 4214 Aff Aff on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R3 4113 4060 Aff Aff on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R3 4161 4209 Aff Aff on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R2 4210 4164 Aff Neg on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R1 4154 4029 Neg Neg on a 2-1
NCFL Grand National Tournament 5/25/2019 PF R1 4203 4147 Aff Neg on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 IPF Octa Half Hollow Hills HS East AS Schreiber GL Neg Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 VPF Quarte Trinity BD Dalton YC Aff Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF5 Bethlehem Central School District DZ Schreiber ST Neg
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF3 Bronx HS Of Science SK Half Hollow Hills HS East IG Neg
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF3 Scarsdale JS Hunter CB Neg
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF2 Great Neck South XN Bronx HS Of Science OP Aff
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF2 Chaminade ST Jericho PC Neg
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF1 Hunter HS Monticello FT Aff
NYSFL State Championship 4/6/2019 NPF PF1 Syosset NZ Bronx HS Of Science SY Neg
NYCFL Grand Tournament 3/16/2019 PF R2 Stuyvesant CR Hunter BA Neg Neg on a 2-0
New York City District Tournament 2/22/2019 PF R6 1205 1217 Neg Aff on a 2-1
New York City District Tournament 2/22/2019 PF R4 1221 1210 Neg Neg on a 3-0
New York City District Tournament 2/22/2019 PF R3 1205 1222 Aff Aff on a 3-0
New York City District Tournament 2/22/2019 PF R3 1214 1216 Neg Neg on a 3-0
New York City District Tournament 2/22/2019 PF R2 1215 1219 Neg
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 JVPF IPFQ Suzhou North America SZ Dipont Education Management WG Neg Neg on a 2-1
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 VPF R6 American Heritage Plantation SS Newton South KC Aff
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 VPF R6 Nightingale Bamford DM Potomac CW Aff
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 VPF R3 Newton South ZS Bridgewater IM Neg
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 VPF R2 Edgemont SM Myers Park CC Neg
45th Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/16/2019 VPF R2 Cary WM Walt Whitman LO Neg
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF Double Millburn AZ Ridge RW Neg Neg on a 2-1
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R6 Montgomery Blair HW Flower Mound HC Aff
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R6 Summit SY Timber Creek BeSh Neg
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R4 Byram Hills BB Midwood TP Neg
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R4 Haverford AL Urban HW Neg
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R1 Winston Churchill GW West Windsor SK Neg
44th University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/8/2019 VPF R1 Winston Churchill LZ Downingtown STEM RH Neg
The Newark Invitational 1/3/2019 VPF R5 Delbarton GM Lawrenceville ZL Aff
The Newark Invitational 1/3/2019 VPF R4 Ridge WK Leadership and Public Service CS Aff
The Newark Invitational 1/3/2019 VPF R2 Delbarton FW Ridge RW Neg
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF Semis Delbarton WF Montville SP Aff Neg on a 2-1
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF Octas Dalton FC Montville SP Neg Neg on a 3-0
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF Dubs Delbarton WF Stuyvesant HA Aff Aff on a 3-0
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF R4 Montville LT Delbarton GM Neg
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF R2 Princeton HD Horace Mann CG Aff
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF R1 Delbarton SK Chaminade GD Aff
The Ridge Debates 12/7/2018 VPF R1 Horace Mann MG Bridgewater Raritan CJ Neg
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF Double Ft Lauderdale FK Horace Mann JS Aff Aff on a 2-1
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF Run Of Hunter LK Bronx HS Of Science NK Neg Aff on a 2-1
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R7 Scarsdale CT Freehold Township KS Aff
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R7 Strath Haven KS Schreiber FS Neg
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R5 Newton South MZ Spence LF Neg
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R5 Bard HS Early College Queens SM Syosset SW Neg
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R4 Wayland WW Monticello YL Aff
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R4 Hunter TR Summit SY Aff
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R2 Riverdale Country GB Freehold Township TG Aff
The Princeton Classic 11/30/2018 PF R2 Timothy Christian GR Delbarton MP Neg
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD Double Paramus GG Hunter TR Neg Neg on a 2-1
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD R5 Paramus GG Richard Montgomery LW Aff
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD R4 Potomac LW Summit SS Neg
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD R3 Strath Haven KZ Our Lady Of Good Counsel GW Neg
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD R1 Cary SH JR Masterman PB Aff
Villiger 39 St Josephs University 11/17/2018 PFD R1 Bronx HS Of Science SG Livingston LS Neg
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF Octa BroHS SK Edgemo KS Aff Aff on a 2-1
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF Partia Urban WH BroHS ZE Aff Aff on a 3-0
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF R5 BerCou DS Hunter RT Neg
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF R4 Ridge MS Dalton CS Aff
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF R3 Summit HO Hackle AK Aff
The 15th Scarsdale Invitational 11/10/2018 VPF R1 Stuyve CL Hunter AK Neg
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R3 Master GF BroHS LC Aff
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R3 Stuyve SG BroHS LO Neg
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R2 Stuyve LK BroHS MZ Neg
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R2 Stuyve AA BroHS YL Neg
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R1 BroHS MS Master SM Aff
Regis Debate NYCFL 10/20/2018 NPF R1 Master CH BroHS GB Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 IPF Octa Jericho PZ Trinity BM Neg Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF Dubs Schreiber GL Jericho LL Neg Neg on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF Dubs Hackley AK Stuyvesant SM Neg Neg on a 3-0
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF PF4 Benjamin N Cardozo CD Bronx HS Of Science ER Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF PF4 Roslyn MR Brooklyn Latin CB Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF PF3 Bronx HS Of Science WB Jericho DC Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 NPF PF3 Benjamin N Cardozo AK Wheatley JJ Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 IPF PF2 Half Hollow Hills HS East AS Syosset KV Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/28/2018 IPF PF2 Al-Noor RT Half Hollow Hills HS East BB Neg
NYCFL Grand Tournament 3/17/2018 PF R1 Stuyvesant AF Collegiate AJ Aff Aff on a 2-0
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 JVPF IPFQ BC Academy HL New Horizons DN GO Aff Aff on a 3-0
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 JVPF Triple Nightingale Bamford IL St. John's KM Neg Neg on a 2-1
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 JVPF R5 Nightingale Bamford JC Newton South KM Neg
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 JVPF R5 Beijing No.55 HS International Student Se HL Vancouver ST Neg
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 NPF R3 Ivy Bridge HK Kugnus ACTS KL Aff
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 NPF R3 St. Michael`s AH City College Academy of the Arts CM Aff
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 NPF R2 Potomac OW Peter's Debate Institute QL Neg
44th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/17/2018 NPF R2 Waring KS Miami Beach Senior MM Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF Octos Poly Prep Country Day BK West Orange BS Aff Aff on a 3-0
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF Double Bridgewater-Raritan IT Half Hollow Hills GT Neg Neg on a 3-0
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF Runoff Horace Mann SJ Poly Prep Country Day DR Neg Aff on a 2-1
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R6 Ridge LR Millburn ZC Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R5 Byram Hills BB Walt Whitman KP Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R5 DuPont Manual JS Union Catholic JJ Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R4 Union Catholic GM Walt Whitman GG Neg
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R4 Walt Whitman HL Bronx HS Of Science DH Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R2 Poly Prep Country Day DW Bronx HS Of Science MiSa Aff
43rd University of Pennsylvania Tournament 2/9/2018 VPF R2 Bronx HS Of Science AW Unionville WG Neg
Newark Invitational 1/4/2018 VPF R3 Bronx HS Of Science JM Bergen County Academies DP Aff
Newark Invitational 1/4/2018 VPF R2 Delbarton LT Independent - HSAS AS Neg
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R5 Hunter XA Riverdale Country BrWi Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R5 Princeton MM Riverdale Country FG Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R4 Delbarton TL Bridgewater-Raritan IJ Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R4 Delbarton FW Bronx HS Of Science RS Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R2 Summit PG Timothy Christian LM Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R2 Riverdale Country GB Chaminade FM Neg
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R1 Freehold Township GA Horace Mann KK Aff
Ridge Debates 12/8/2017 VPF R1 Dalton HR Princeton DH Aff
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD Quarte Livingston RT Strath Haven LS Neg Neg on a 3-0
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD R4 Dalton HF Bronx HS Of Science DH Neg
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD R4 Bronx HS Of Science NH Georgetown Day ER Aff
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD R3 Achievement First Brooklyn GE Oxbridge Academy of the Palm Beaches GW Neg
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD R2 Bronx HS Of Science LR Our Lady of Good Counsel High Sch TT Aff
Villiger 38 St Josephs University 11/18/2017 PFD R2 Unionville KR Dalton MR Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF Octa Half Hollow Hills GT Stuyvesant SS Aff Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF Dub Syosset CR Horace Mann FS Neg Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF5 Hunter BB Nightingale Bamford LI Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF5 Trinity LS Berkeley Carroll FM Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF4 Schreiber JK Great Neck South CB Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF4 Jericho RL Syosset LL Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 NPF PF2 Horace Mann GW Webster Thomas BV Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 NPF PF2 Hunter AL Schreiber FS Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF1 Al-Noor DS Schreiber TK Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/29/2017 IPF PF1 Horace Mann MK Great Neck South AC Aff
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R5 Capitol Debate LP Potomac YB Aff
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R5 Clear Lake MM Potomac MM Neg
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R3 Spence RS Pine View RL Aff
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R3 Southlake Carroll JD summit high school PG Neg
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R1 Potomac Debate LC Cranbrook Kingswood Upper RW Neg
43rd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/18/2017 VPF R1 Strake Jesuit Prep SP Millburn BZ Neg
Malcolm A Bump Memorial Tournament 2/4/2017 APF R3 Success Academy BM Bronx HS Of Science OS Aff
Malcolm A Bump Memorial Tournament 2/4/2017 APF R3 Byram Hills SJ Success Academy MF Aff
Malcolm A Bump Memorial Tournament 2/4/2017 APF R1 Byram Hills SB Success Academy BS Aff
Malcolm A Bump Memorial Tournament 2/4/2017 APF R1 Bronx HS Of Science DP Spence RL Neg
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF quarte Hackley WT Poly Prep Country Day FS Aff Aff on a 3-0
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF octa Hackley WT Princeton BC Aff Aff on a 2-1
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R6 Riverdale Country WK Lakeland DT Aff
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R6 Delbarton BR Lexington LH Neg
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R4 Lexington BC Success Academy TC Aff
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R3 Delbarton TS Lakeland TM Aff
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R2 Princeton LS Hunter CT Aff
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R2 Poly Prep Country Day FS Dalton SC Neg
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R1 Lakeland ST Hackley FT Neg
The 13th Scarsdale Invitational 11/11/2016 VPF R1 Hackley FZ Timothy Christian KR Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 VPF Quarte Chaminade SC Bronx HS Of Science BZ Neg Aff on a 2-1
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 VPF Part O Dalton UH Poly Prep Country Day AA Aff Aff on a 3-0
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 IPF PF5 Mount Markham Central FM Poly Prep Country Day MC Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 IPF PF5 Great Neck South SW Half Hollow Hills CI Aff
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF3 Schreiber KT Half Hollow Hills KC Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF3 Syosset LV Nightingale Bamford DM Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF2 Franklin AS Al-Noor SI Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF2 Great Neck South KP Bronx HS Of Science VZ Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF1 Christ the King BB Berkeley Carroll MS Neg
NYSFL State Championship Tournament 4/9/2016 NPF PF1 Syosset JL Jericho PW Neg
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF Semifi Newton South SG Dalton CM Aff Aff on a 3-2
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF Quarte Boca Raton Community BF Stuyvesant AS Aff Aff on a 3-0
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF Triple Ransom Everglades SH Trinity LW Aff Aff on a 3-0
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R6 Beijing No. 35 CL Dipont CY Aff
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R6 Hendrickson VP Kugnus ACTS CC Aff
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R5 Ft. Lauderdale TP Hawken KZ Neg
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R5 Puyallup MR Liaoning Experimental ZY Aff
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R3 Horace Mann GR NSDA China PY Neg
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R3 Delbarton GB HS Affiliated to South China Normal ZK Aff
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R1 Kingwood EP Boca Raton Community RG Aff
42nd Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament 2/11/2016 JVPF R1 NSDA China ZL Delbarton GG Aff
2016 Newark Invitational 1/7/2016 NPF Quarte Byram Hills OJ Bronx HS Of Science KI Neg Neg on a 3-0
2016 Newark Invitational 1/7/2016 NPF R3 Success Academy PC Millburn JG Neg
2016 Newark Invitational 1/7/2016 NPF R1 Bronx HS Of Science SK Capitol Debate HP Aff