Jia (Anita) Pan Paradigm

Last changed 13 January 2021 7:47 AM EDT

Debated policy for Brooklyn Technical High School (2013-2016) and for Binghamton University (2016-2020). You can add me to the email chain at jpan2541@bths.edu

TLDR been out of debate for a while, have very little familiarity with the topic so please explain acronyms, topic specific knowledge, etc... You can probably run anything (nothing offensive) and I'll evaluate it. While I enjoy K debates more, I'm not particularly against debates about policies as I started out as a non-K debater. I prefer depth over breath and think line-by-line is important. Since debate is now on Zoom, please be very clear using changes in tone, inflection, etc to ensure that I am evaluating the arguments you want me to evaluate.

I'm just going to copy and paste a portion of Lee Thach's paradigm here because it basically summarizes how I evaluate debates:

"1. Clarity > Loudness > Speed.

2. Framing > Impact > Solvency. Framing is a prior question. Don’t let me interpret the debate, interpret the debate for me.

3. Truth IS Tech. Warranting, comparative analysis, and clash structure the debate.

4. Offense vs Defense: Defense supports offense, though it's possible to win on pure defense.

5. Try or Die vs Neg on Presumption: I vote on case turns & solvency takeouts. AFF needs sufficient offense and defense for me to vote on Try or Die."

Here are some of my other thoughts:

Kritiks: I mostly ran critical arguments including ones about anti-blackness and biopower. I like Ks and when good K debates happen. One thing that has changed for me in terms of Ks is that I want to hear that the K does "something" whatever that "something" is. Whether in round or external to the debate, please explain what that "something" is, why I should evaluate whatever the K does as "something," and how exactly the K does that thing.

FW: I would say that I'm probably 51/49 against framework. I think that it is sometimes valuable to discuss non-traditional affirmatives especially when the affirmative has given me reasons why their AFF is valuable to this year's resolution. I do enjoy framework for certain AFFs that are abusive/irrelevant. That said, my bias can be overcome with good debating (i.e. when standards/violations are super nuanced and when there are clear articulations/comparisons of each side's model of debate and why they're good/bad)

CPs/Piks: I love them. Flex your creativity as much as possible. I can also be convinced why particular CPs/Piks can be abusive.

DAs: I will evaluate all types of DA but just please have uniqueness and be very clear about your internal links. Contrary to popular opinion, I like politics DAs.

Miscellaneous: I like jokes and the like that make debates entertaining and enjoyable so if you can make me laugh I'll probably boost your speaks. Troll debates are cool too but only when the arguments actually apply and can sorta make sense.

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
47th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2021-02-12 VCX Dbls Univ Of Chicago Lab KO Edina AA Aff Aff 3-0
47th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2021-02-12 VCX R7 Princeton PT Little Rock Central GR Neg
47th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2021-02-12 JVCX R6 Berkeley Prep WiWe Bronx Science DT Neg
47th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2021-02-12 VCX R4 Thomas Jefferson HSST XD Liberal Arts and Science BR Neg
47th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2021-02-12 NCX R3 Berkeley Prep CS Little Rock Central ML Aff
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-T Octafi Bronx Science CM Leland LZ Aff Aff 3-0
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-N R6 ADL CT Parker RL Neg
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-T R5 Carmel Valley Independent LR Lexington BO Aff
35th Annual Stanford Invitational 2021-02-06 CX-N R4 Aurorae Young CC ADL CW Aff
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-T R3 Sonoma KP Damien DT Aff
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-T R2 Lexington FR Georgetown Day BL Neg
35th Annual Stanford Invitational HS 2021-02-06 CX-O R1 Silver Creek GK Garfield SP Aff
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 Pol Semis Jesuit MR Shark RW Aff Aff 2-1
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 NCX Quarte Barsto OS Westwo MS Aff Aff 3-0
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 NCX Octos Westwo MS SMSOT DM Aff Aff 2-1
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 Pol Double Barsto BM Westwo LX Neg Aff 2-1
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 NCX R5 Westwo GS Barsto OS Neg
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 NCX R3 Kickap RC Jesuit FC Aff
The Cougar Classic at the University of Houston HS 2021-01-14 Pol R2 Aubrey OM LanCre DI Aff
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 Novi FINALS George Mason BP Liberty CP Neg Neg 3-0
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 Open Quarte Baylor MT RutNew OS Neg Aff 2-1
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 Open O2 GeoMas JT RutNew OS Aff
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 Open O1 Baylor MT RutNew BK Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2020 HS 2020-02-27 VCX R5 Lexington KR Georgetown Day BS Neg
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2020 MS 2020-02-27 VCX R4 SA Midtown West DW SA Harlem West SG Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2020 HS 2020-02-27 VCX R2 University WR SA Midtown West MP Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2020 MS 2020-02-27 VCX R1 SA Ditmas Park PD Lexington CH Neg
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX Octas Liberal Arts and Science EU Northview YA Aff Aff 3-0
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX Dbls Bronx Science CM Henry W Grady NW Neg Neg 2-1
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament MS 2020-02-13 JVCX R7 SA Harlem West BB Mamaroneck FB Aff
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX R6 Liberal Arts and Science MM Lindale PH Aff
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament MS 2020-02-13 JVCX R5 Mamaroneck ZP SA Harlem North Central DT Neg
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX R4 Lexington KT Liberal Arts and Science GP Neg
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX R3 Mamaroneck LR Lexington CM Aff
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX R2 Edina SA Maine East SS Aff
46th Annual Harvard National Forensics Tournament HS 2020-02-13 VCX R1 Charlestown CP Edina AB Neg
Big Lex HS 2020-01-18 VCX R6 Bronx Science MC Stuyvesant CN Aff
Big Lex HS 2020-01-18 VCX R5 Wylie E. Groves GL Newark Tech TN Neg
Big Lex HS 2020-01-18 VCX R4 SWW EC Newark Science CS Neg
Big Lex HS 2020-01-18 VCX R3 Berkeley Prep SS Newark Science SQ Aff
Big Lex HS 2020-01-18 VCX R2 Berkeley Prep SZ North Broward Prep AR Aff
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 Novi N6 Monmouth GG George Mason PP Neg
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 Novi N5 George Mason OV NewSchool BK Aff
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 Novi N4 Liberty PS George Mason HS Neg
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 Novi N3 NYU BL Liberty GJ Neg
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 Novi N2 Cornell SY George Mason BG Aff
Binghamton 2nd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2019-09-20 JV R1 Liberty CS George Mason ST Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R6 Bronx HS Of Science CM Lexington TH Neg
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R5 Baltimore City TP Bronx HS Of Science CR Neg
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R4 Leon Goldstein AF Lexington CH Neg
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R3 Newark Science SC Leon Goldstein CK Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R2 Stuyvesant (Independent) FC Lexington CB Aff
Lakeland Westchester Classic 2019 HS 2019-02-28 VCX R1 Leon Goldstein PC Lexington BY Neg
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 CX Octos Lexington BY Strath Haven LZ Aff Aff 3-0
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 JVCX R5 Lexington WG Okemos NS Aff
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 CX R4 Thomas Jefferson PY Lexington LZ Aff
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 CX R3 Lexington PJ Bronx Science CM Neg
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 CX R2 Baltimore City WF Lexington CA Neg
Pennsbury Falcon Invitational HS 2019-02-01 CX R1 Lexington TC Strath Haven LZ Neg
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open Quarte North Star Academy CPHS DT Lexington LL Aff Aff 3-0
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R6 Newark Science BO Unionville KL Neg
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R5 Dr Izquierdo Health and Science Charter RP Leon M. Goldstein FC Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R4 Lexington LL Stuyvesant FC Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R3 North Star Academy CPHS BO Lexington MW Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R2 North Star Academy CPHS DT Baltimore City WM Neg
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2018-11-29 Open R1 Baltimore City RS Lexington ML Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2018-10-12 CX R6 Nevada Union AN Unionville AP Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament MS 2018-10-12 CX R5 Georgetown Day MW SA Harlem North Central DD Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2018-10-12 CX R1 North Star Academy CPHS TD Dr Izquierdo Health and Science Charter PR Aff
SNFI Intensive Week Rounds 2018-08-06 CX R6 Tr@ns18rs Lee & Qin Wogey Hoagies Wogan & Doctorman Neg
SNFI Intensive Week Rounds HS 2018-08-06 CX R5 Tr@ns18rs Lee & Qin Perm Droppers Gipson & Fang Neg
SNFI Intensive Week Rounds HS 2018-08-06 CX R4 Perm Droppers Gipson & Fang Wogey Hoagies Wogan & Doctorman Neg
SNFI Intensive Week Rounds HS 2018-08-06 CX R2 Cerberus Brar & Ipe Wogey Hoagies Wogan & Doctorman Neg
SNFI Intensive Week Rounds HS 2018-08-06 CX R1 Tr@ns18rs Lee & Qin Cerberus Brar & Ipe Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL Double FFGSV RK Barstow DT Aff Aff 3-0
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R7 JM Lab GK MMMR CT Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R6 Classic MP FD Classic KAZ GY Aff
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R5 K Lab BS CPPWW KQ Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes 2018-07-31 POL R4 HJPPV AhBh Hybrid EK Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R3 K Lab CW Hybrid HM Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R2 HJPPV BS New Marx KS Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes HS 2018-07-31 POL R1 FFGSV SB BFHPR FP Neg
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 VCX Quarte North Star Academy CPHS DS Lexington JR Aff Neg 2-1
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 VCX R5 Lexington HZ Whitney Young PW Aff
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 VCX R4 Lexington JR Hunter CL Aff
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 VCX R3 Lexington QH Success Academy Manhattan BR Neg
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 NCX R2 Lexington ME Mamaroneck SC Neg
Westchester Classic at Lakeland High School HS 2018-03-01 VCX R1 Whitney Young JT Lexington LL Neg
Lexington Winter Invitational HS 2018-01-13 VCX Octos North Star Academy CPHS YF Okemos RR Aff Neg 2-1
Lexington Winter Invitational HS 2018-01-13 VCX R4 Baltimore City PL Bronx HS Of Science BL Aff
Lexington Winter Invitational HS 2018-01-13 VCX R2 Bronx HS Of Science ST McDonogh ZW Neg
Lexington Winter Invitational HS 2018-01-13 VCX R1 Univ Of Chicago Lab PL Baltimore City SS Aff
Newark Invitational HS 2018-01-04 VPD Quarte North Star Academy CPHS DY Hunter AJ Aff Aff 3-0
Newark Invitational HS 2018-01-04 VPD R2 North Star Academy CPHS AK Dr Izquierdo Health and Science Charter RP Aff
Newark Invitational HS 2018-01-04 NPD R1 North Star Academy CPHS GW Leon M. Goldstein DK Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open Quarte Stuyvesant DS Lexington AC Neg Neg 2-1
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open R6 Edgemont TT Baltimore City LP Neg
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open R4 Stuyvesant CA North Broward Prep MR Neg
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open R3 Baltimore City CG Stuyvesant CH Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open R2 Lexington LL Bronx HS Of Science BL Aff
NY Fall Faceoff at Mamaroneck HS HS 2017-12-01 Open R1 Stuyvesant FW Lexington CH Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2017-10-13 CX Sextod Georgetown Day BB Morrison CC Aff Aff 3-0
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2017-10-13 CX R6 Newark Tech EM Baltimore City WM Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2017-10-13 CX R3 Lexington JR North Star Academy CPHS YD Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2017-10-13 CX R2 Newark Tech RM Stuyvesant WF Neg
Yale Invitational HS 2017-09-15 CX R4 University ER Lexington MC Neg
Yale Invitational HS 2017-09-15 CX R3 Hunter AJ Lexington ZL Neg
Yale Invitational HS 2017-09-15 CX R2 Lexington LL Loyola HS of Detroit BM Aff
Yale Invitational HS 2017-09-15 CX R1 Lexington TA Mamaroneck RK Aff
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R5 CFJ WW Munday/Tallungan HS Aff
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R4 HJPPV HN Munday/Tallungan HR Aff
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R3 HJPPV BP BCPPR MN Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R3 AFKKMM HP BCPPR HP Aff
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R2 BCPPR KL BFHHR LP Neg
Michigan Summer Institutes 2017-08-01 POL R1 BFHHR DK AFKKMM FM Aff
NYCUDL High School State Championship HS 2017-04-01 NPF Octafi Edgemont BY Academy of American Studies RF Pro Pro 3-0
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Open Semifi Lexington RJ Edgemont SM Aff Neg 2-1
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Nov Semifi Baltimore City CB Stuyvesant AC Neg Neg 3-0
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Nov R5 Lexington TC North Star Academy ST Neg
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Open R4 North Star Academy MO Hunter CS Neg
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Open R3 Stuyvesant DS Newark Science MM Aff
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Nov R2 North Star Academy MI Stuyvesant MV Neg
NY Fall Face Off at Mamaroneck HS HS 2016-12-03 Open R1 North Broward Preparatory MR Newark Science SA Aff
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2016-10-14 CX R5 Morrison CS North Broward Preparatory MR Neg
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2016-10-14 CX R3 Newark Science MP North Star Academy AW Aff