Xingkai Liu Paradigm

Last changed 12/4 4:57P EDT

I debate for the University of Miami. Here are somethings you want to keep in mind when I am your judge:

 

1). I hate untopical bullshit affs. Those affs are just cheating strategies, intolerable.

2). I have a high threshold for voting on theory. But if you completely drop the conditionality argument, for example, I will vote you down.

3). Make sure during your speech you tell me a coherent story, and that includes Uniqueness, link, internal link and impact.

4). If you are doing a Kritik, make sure you explain the link and the alternative very well.

5). Framework debate is important in clashing debates (policy vs critical).

 

 

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Ibis Debates at the University of Miami 12/3/2016 R2 Carrollton School of the Sacred Heart CS Christopher Columbus VP Neg
Ibis Debates at the University of Miami 12/5/2015 R2 North Broward Preparatory MG Cypress Bay JD Aff
Ibis Debates at the University of Miami 12/5/2015 R1 Carrollton School of the Sacred Heart RA Ft. Lauderdale CA Aff