Wayne Campbell Paradigm

Last changed Sun, Jul 2, 2017 at 9:56 PM UTC

Background

Debated a year for Petoskey

MSU 2018, currently debating

 

Email Chain

Please use one and put me on it: waynec5119@gmail.com

Email>Pocketbox but I won't be bitter.

 

Clipping

Seems to be a problem. If you do it and if I catch you, then I will drop you. 

 

Pre-round synopsis

I don't think anything in my paradigm deviates from the norm enough for you to spend pre-round prep reading it. I could be wrong. 

You should debate what you are best at. I’ve voted for every genre of argument. There are some arguments my record seems to favor, but I don't think it's usually significant enough to justify a change in your strategy. 

I think the primary purpose of debate is and should be to learn, research, and make reasoned arguments about a contested resolution. As such, I try to defer to what is actually debated and often vote against what I think is true. 

 

Other predispositions written below are thoughts I have about arguments in the abstract. That is all it is and sometimes it changes faster than this page gets edited. I think it's pretty reliable though. 

 

Topicality

I’ve done some preseason research on the topic and judged some debates, but I don’t have a strong normative predisposition about what the topic should look like. If you want to win on topicality, you should use the opportunity to craft that vision for me. “Core of the topic” cues are not something that will click as well with me because I don’t have a strong vision of what that should be/is.

  

K Affs/FW

Affs should have, at least, some sort of fundamental relationship to the topic. 

I'm not sure if fairness is an intrinsic good. 

I don't see a strong connection between debating a topical plan and producing activism or better activism. I'm more amenable to predictable limits arguments, and the education that those limits are more likely to consistently produce I do think is an intrinsic good.  

I think I vote aff when the 2NR goes for FW >60% of the time. This isn’t because I dislike FW, but because a lot of the time the aff has a set of impact-turns to FW that they win the technical debate on. I think that a good defense of why the neg’s interp doesn’t preclude the themes of the aff coupled with impact calculus can remedy that.  

Competing methodologies is persuasive... I think the aff getting to apply traditional standards of competition into K debate makes it very difficult to be negative. 

 

Kritiks

I’m really frustrated with some of Michigan’s reliance of super generic kritiks that rely on links of omission or really non-central assumptions of the aff in order to win. I don’t hate all kritik debates…. I don’t think… I just would prefer it if the debates were more case-specific. 

 

Case Debates

Are something that Michigan debate needs more of— even if you debate kritikally. A lot of affirmatives’ internal links don’t stand to scrutiny and smart analytical presses early on go a long way and increase your speaker points. 

 

Theory/CPs

Unless it’s perf con and/or conditionality, it’s almost always a reason to reject the argument. Process/agent/condition counterplans are probably bad. PICs I’m down with if they exclude large enough portions of the aff such that the aff should seem to have to defend them. Heavily neg on conditionality. I lean more neg than I otherwise would on all theory questions if it's a new aff or if it is not a new aff but is still undisclosed (that last bit is more Michigan-specific). 

 

Presumption

Is towards less change 

 

 

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Event Rd Aff Neg Decision
MIFA Debate State Finals 12/8/2017 N POL Novice R1 Traverse City Central FO Detroit Country Day AH AFF Traverse City Central FO
MIFA Debate State Finals 12/8/2017 V POL Varsity R5 Detroit Country Day GX H.H. Dow MD AFF Detroit Country Day GX
MIFA Debate State Finals 12/8/2017 N POL Semis Detroit Country Day SL H.H. Dow PV NEG H.H. Dow PV
H.H. Dow PV on a 3-0
University of Michigan HS Debate Tournament 11/1/2017 NCX 3 Glenbrook North CF Westminster KS NEG Westminster KS
University of Michigan HS Debate Tournament 11/1/2017 VCX 5 Theodore Roosevelt KM Pace NS NEG Pace NS
University of Michigan HS Debate Tournament 11/1/2017 VCX 6 Lane Tech LM Westminster IM NEG Westminster IM
University of Michigan HS Debate Tournament 11/1/2017 VCX 7 Lane Tech CH Glenbrook South AK AFF Lane Tech CH
Groves Falcon Invitational 10/27/2017 VP 2 University Prep Science and Math HT Detroit Country Day XR NEG Detroit Country Day XR
Groves Falcon Invitational 10/27/2017 VP 4 University RV H.H. Dow WW NEG H.H. Dow WW
Groves Falcon Invitational 10/27/2017 VP 5 H.H. Dow SY Detroit Country Day NN AFF H.H. Dow SY
Groves Falcon Invitational 10/27/2017 VP 6 H.H. Dow WW Detroit Country Day XR NEG Detroit Country Day XR
H.H. Dow WW on a 2-1
Groves Falcon Invitational 10/27/2017 VP 7 H.H. Dow WW West Bloomfield AB NEG West Bloomfield AB
West Bloomfield AB on a 3-0
Okemos High School Invitational 10/13/2017 NPF PFN1 TraCit SL SalineM ZD PRO TraCit SL
Okemos High School Invitational 10/13/2017 NP PN2 H.HDow PH DetCou AL NEG DetCou AL
Okemos High School Invitational 10/13/2017 NP PN3 DetCou SW DetCou HS AFF DetCou SW
Okemos High School Invitational 10/13/2017 OP PO5 H.HDow WW WesBlo AP AFF H.HDow WW
Okemos High School Invitational 10/13/2017 NP Final H.HDow PV DetCou FL AFF H.HDow PV
H.HDow PV on a 2-1
MIFA Novice Debate State Finals 17 12/9/2016 NPol 1 Portage Northern A Wylie E. Groves B NEG Wylie E. Groves B
MIFA Novice Debate State Finals 17 12/9/2016 NPol 2 Okemos B Wylie E. Groves A AFF Okemos B
MIFA Novice Debate State Finals 17 12/9/2016 NPol 3 West Bloomfield B Kingsley A NEG Kingsley A
MIFA Novice Debate State Finals 17 12/9/2016 NPol 5 H.H. Dow A West Bloomfield A AFF H.H. Dow A
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 1 Okemos ML Mona Shores BS AFF Okemos ML
Okemos ML on a 3-0
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 NVP 2 West Bloomfield high school LH Wylie E. Groves BS NEG Wylie E. Groves BS
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 NVP 3 H.H. Dow WW West Ottawa LG AFF H.H. Dow WW
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 NVP 5 H.H. Dow MY Traverse City Central BB AFF H.H. Dow MY
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 1 BGMP Wang & Luo BBHT Morales & Park NEG BBHT Morales & Park
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 2 RRSW Heiblum & Desmukh RRSW Mazets & Nottingham AFF RRSW Heiblum & Desmukh
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 3 BGMP Srinivasan & Abdullah RRSW Mukherjee & Nanji AFF BGMP Srinivasan & Abdullah
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 4 GMRS Lim & Bahri GMRS Ratakonda & Sears NEG GMRS Ratakonda & Sears
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 5 GMRS Bahansali & Redman ORS Pickert & Chen AFF GMRS Bahansali & Redman
SDI 4 Week Tournament 8/2/2016 PD 6 RRSW Goldberg & Roberts BBHT Zhao & Witteman AFF RRSW Goldberg & Roberts
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 1/8/2016 VPol 2 Traverse City Central Detroit Country Day AFF Traverse City Central
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 1/8/2016 VPol 3 Wylie E Groves West Bloomfield NEG West Bloomfield
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 1 Detroit Country Day VX Portage Northern MV AFF Detroit Country Day VX
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 2 Loyola HS of Detroit MW H.H. Dow DP NEG H.H. Dow DP
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 3 Oakwood EP H.H. Dow US NEG H.H. Dow US
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 4 H.H. Dow NP Portage Northern PG NEG Portage Northern PG
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 5 West Bloomfield high school HW Detroit Country Day FG AFF West Bloomfield high school HW
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 6 H.H. Dow US Detroit Country Day SB AFF H.H. Dow US
H.H. Dow US on a 3-0
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 7 Traverse City Central AF Seaholm LP AFF Traverse City Central AF
Traverse City Central AF on a 3-0
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 1 Portage Northern GP ArbPrep CL AFF Portage Northern GP
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 NOV 2 University Prep BL Groves AB NEG Groves AB
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 3 DCD VX Portage Northern SP AFF DCD VX
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 4 Groves LW WestBloom HH NEG WestBloom HH
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 5 DCD HG Oakw RH AFF DCD HG
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 6 Portage Northern GP DCD VX NEG DCD VX
Portage Northern GP on a 2-1
SDI 4 Week Tournament 7/28/2015 CX 1 BDRS Falkenstein & Lu BEPST Grossman & Stryker NEG BEPST Grossman & Stryker
SDI 4 Week Tournament 7/28/2015 CX 2 BDRS Patel & Yang BEPST Abramson & Barov NEG BEPST Abramson & Barov
SDI 4 Week Tournament 7/28/2015 CX 3 BHL Berlin & Harrington GMSS Freedline & Gaur NEG GMSS Freedline & Gaur
SDI 4 Week Tournament 7/28/2015 CX 4 BDRS Wilson & Wang BDRS Donapati & Chintalapudi AFF BDRS Wilson & Wang
SDI 4 Week Tournament 7/28/2015 CX 6 GMSS Dalal & Ye Hybrid Bhavsar & Reddy NEG Hybrid Bhavsar & Reddy
SDI 4 Week Mini Tournament 7/18/2015 CX Round 1 BDRS Goyal & Nguyen GMMS Ren & Trejo AFF BDRS Goyal & Nguyen
SDI 4 Week Mini Tournament 7/18/2015 CX Round 3 GMMS Mudter & Renkis HRS Larson & Patel NEG HRS Larson & Patel
SDI 4 Week Mini Tournament 7/18/2015 CX Round 4 BHL Gokare & Luo BDRS Abney & Malwade AFF BHL Gokare & Luo