Leo Petrowski Paradigm

Last changed Sun, Oct 30, 2016 at 10:03 AM UTC

Debate Background: I debated for four years at Petoskey High School, and I am currently a sophomore at University of Michigan; I debated at U of M my freshman year. I am more used to policy arguments, but that doesn't mean I won't vote on critical stuff, that just means you will have to explain it more depth.

Philosophy: I will vote on pretty much any argument, but you need to tell me what the role of the ballot is. I need to know how I should frame the debate in order to vote properly. If no one tells me what the role of the ballot is I will default to the team that I think debated the best. So tab.

Specific Arguments:

1) Theory- I generally think theory debates are boring, and either side should only go for theory when absolutely necessary. If it is argued well and has warrants I will vote on it, but I'm not a huge fan.

2) Kritiks- Kritiks are fine arguments, but make sure I understand it, and you understand it. At some point you will need to give me a coherent explanation of the K, and the alt. K affs are fine as well, but I will probably be inclined to vote neg on T if it is brought up and argued well. Other psuedo-kritikal arguments should just be explained well then I don't care if you run it. P.S. you have to win framework if it is brought up in order to win the K.

3) Counterplans- Counterplans are great. Have a net benefit, and win the perm debate and you will probably win the round. Delay, consult and other PICs of the like can be annoying, but like I said, just win the perm debate :)

4) Topicality- Don't go for topicality unless they completely drop it OR the plan REALLY isn't topical.

5) Disadvantages- Great. Do it. I will vote on it.

6) Case- Good clash on case makes me happy. A negative can't win on just case defense though for the most part. In that situation I usually would give some risk of solvency or some risk of the impacts, so have offense on case or a DA, CP or Alt on a K as well as case defense.

In round Conduct: Be respectful. Nothing irritates me more than when people are rude to their opponents, or yell at each other in cross-ex. This is a debate round not a middle school cafeteria.

Prep/speech Time: I will keep you speech and prep time, and my time counts, not yours. Also don't steal prep. That's not a cool thing to do. I don't take prep for flashing or emailing, but if I notice you steal prep time you will lose speaks.

CX: If you make an argument in CX you have to bring it up in a constructive or rebuttal speech in order for it to be weighed in the round. Good CX questions and answers = good speaks.

Speed: Speed is necessary in the way that policy debate has evolved, but make sure you are clear. If you aren't clear I won't yell at you, but I might not hear your argument to flow it, and if I don't flow the argument then it doesn't exist. It helps if you start a little slower than your top speed at the beginning of your first speech that way I can get used to your style. Another note: double breathing annoys me so much, try not to do it please and if you do don't be obnoxious about it.

Other: I'm generally tech over truth, BUT truth outweighs when both sides are similar technically. Also, if either side says something extremely inappropriate along the lines of racist, homophobic, transphobic, ablest etc. speech, then I will give that team VERY VERY low speaks. Be respectful and not a bigot, thanks. If you have any questions, just ask.       

 

 

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Event Rd Aff Neg Decision
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 17 1/6/2017 VPol 2 Okemos RR Traverse City Central FM NEG
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 17 1/6/2017 VPol 3 H.H. Dow DP Wylie E. Groves AC AFF
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 17 1/6/2017 VPol 5 Portage Northern DD Detroit Country Day OT AFF
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 VP 1 West Bloomfield high school AN Mona Shores BM NEG
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 NVP 2 Mona Shores BH H.H. Dow JS NEG
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/4/2016 NVP 5 Wylie E. Groves GS H.H. Dow DM NEG
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 1/8/2016 VPol 4 Portage Northern Detroit Country Day NEG
MIFA Varsity Debate State Finals 1/8/2016 VPol 5 HH Dow West Bloomfield AFF
MIFA Novice States 12/11/2015 NPol 2 HH Dow B Gaylord A AFF
MIFA Novice States 12/11/2015 NPol 3 Okemos A Detroit Country Day B AFF
MIFA Novice States 12/11/2015 NPol 4 Portage Northern B Detroit Country Day A NEG
MIFA Novice States 12/11/2015 NPol 6 Traverse City Central A West Bloomfield A AFF
Traverse C on a 2-1
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 NVP 1 Wylie E. Groves LA Detroit Country Day CC NEG
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 VP 2 West Bloomfield high school HW Detroit Country Day VX AFF
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 NVP 4 Portage Northern RS Detroit Country Day NN NEG
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 NVP 6 Detroit Country Day CC H.H. Dow MY NEG
H.H. Dow M on a 3-0
Groves Falcon Invitational 11/13/2015 NVP 7 H.H. Dow MY Okemos AR NEG
Okemos AR on a 3-0
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 1 Okemos RZ DCD HG AFF
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 NOV 2 Portage Northern RA Groves CL AFF
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 4 Groves GM DCD VX NEG
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 5 Portage Northern GP WestBloom HH NEG
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 6 Oakw WP WestBloom HH NEG
WestBloom on a 3-0
University Prep Panther Classic 11/6/2015 OPN 7 WestBloom HH Portage Northern GP AFF
WestBloom on a 3-0
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 NCX 1 Westminster Schools RF Glenbrook South MDu AFF
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 VCX 2 Johns Creek BT Walter Payton CP MS AFF
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 VCX 4 Johns Creek LR Berkeley Prep SS NEG
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 VCX 5 Niles West CB Glenbrook South DS NEG
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 VCX 6 Wylie E. Groves LW Mt Vernon Presbyterian LM AFF
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 VCX 7 Lane Tech BM West Des Moines Valley GS NEG
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 NCX Octos USN RS Pine Crest SD AFF
USN RS on a 2-1
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 NCX Semis USN RS Westminster Schools KR NEG
USN RS on a 2-1
University of Michigan HS Tournament 10/28/2015 NCX Finals New Trier BE USN RS NEG
New Trier on a 2-1