Jess Spiehler Paradigm

Last changed 12 November 2020 8:52 AM CDT

I am a graduate from the University of Houston :)

My degrees are in Political Science and Philosophy, with a focus on Public Health and Bioethics respectively.

I've been debating since 2010 and I've been doing CX since 2012.

You can probably find my rounds/old wiki's if you want.

I want to be on the e-mail chain: JCSpiehler@gmail.com

COVID Digital Debate Update:

- Please make sure everyone gives a thumbs up or something before you start your speech :,) if my audio is broken, I won't respond to "Is anyone not ready"

- I don't think spreading has translated super well to online debate. I don't know exactly what it is, but the sound quality varies from debater to debater and (more often than not) the words become super muddled together and tinny through my microphone. That said, I have nothing against it and I will evaluate arguments about "speed reading" wholistically. But, if I can't hear what you're saying clearly through my average laptop and headphones then I can't flow the arguments you're making. You might just need to read a little slower than you would in person.

I <3 Debate.

Framework/T: Just because I group these together in my paradigm doesn't mean you get to do it in your debate. There are distinctions between Fw/T. I actually find that these debates can be enjoyable if you use less jargon and more explanation. If the aff does a governmental thing you probably want to be running a variation of T.

DA's: I don't regularly go for DA's but I've (obviously) encountered them often in debate. I remember the first time I really appreciated the 'art of the DisAd' was while watching an outround at Wake. That said, the best thing you can do for me as a judge, is break down the narrative of the DA in relation to the aff. I find it easy to be skeptical of most internal link stories (lazy card cutting?) so make sure you can adequately explain how your politics scenario reasonably leads to your catastrophic impact.

CP's/Pic's: I love tricky Pic's. Counterplans are alright. I think all forms of CP's are a great way to force the aff into defending their methodologies.

Theory: Just because I like Pic's doesn't mean I don't buy that they can be bad. Severance Perms are probably bad. You can pretty much sell me on most theory. But, if it sounds like you're reading backfiles and blocks back and forth to eachother don't expect me to be sufficiently persuaded. If you expect me to vote on theory then treat it like you would any other winning argument.

K aff's: I love a well executed K affs. Anything from a middle of the road affirmatives (also see Policy Affs) to performance. I have voted against these kind of affirmatives on framework (and T) before - so make sure you can defend the pre-fiat implications of the affirmative and why they matter.

Policy Affs: The more detailed the better. Personally, I don't run policy affirmatives - but I do respect people that do. The time and effort put into these arguments really can show. I actually do want to hear about what the world would be like if your plan was passed. You don't have to be hyperbolic about everything.

K's: I love a good kritik. I am persuaded by access arguments made by the affirmative. I am most familiar with Identity Politics kritiks. I've ran Anti-blackness, Afropessimism, Disability Studies, Settler Colonialism, Give Back the Land, Redness, Queer Theory, and Femme. I've also read Bataille (I kind of think he can be right sometimes), Biopolitics (Foucault), Kafka, Agamben, Lacan, D&G, just D, Baudrillard, and I've debated/read most other bizarre kritikal theory out there. I primarily run kritiks (if you look at my neg page on the case wiki you can get an idea).

Speaker Points: I try not to, but I give higher-than-average speaker points. I don't mind sharing CX, but don't answer questions your partner is capable of answering. Wait until your partner deffers to you. Don't interject for them. Also, please don't be rude. You are all human. I am a person, you are all people. We all have feelings, we are all here to learn, we all (hopefully) love debate. Friendly competition is good competition.

Feel free to ask me any questions you might have before the round starts.

My favorite painting.

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
University of Minnesota College Invitational C 2021-01-29 JV R3 Wyoming/Missouri State GW Kansas State WS Aff
University of Minnesota College Invitational C 2021-01-29 Open R2 George Mason PL Liberty SW Aff
University of Minnesota College Invitational C 2021-01-29 Open R1 Kansas ZL Liberty CR Neg
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 JV R6 Liberty CK Purdue AS Neg
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 JV R5 George Mason PL Minnesota DH Aff
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 JV R4 NYU KS Minnesota AS Neg
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 Nov R3 Arizona State/CSU Long Beach WT Liberty MS Aff
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 Nov R2 Cal State Fullerton MC Binghamton WH Neg
ADA Fall C 2020-11-13 JV R1 Boston College CZ Georgia UV Aff
Gonzaga University The Jesuit C 2020-10-30 Nov RD 4 Monmouth PM CSU Long Beach ST Neg
Gonzaga University The Jesuit C 2020-10-30 Open RD 3 Western Washington AB CSU Long Beach FC Neg
Gonzaga University The Jesuit C 2020-10-30 Nov RD 2 Monmouth JR Cal State Fullerton CM Aff
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Open Semis Cornel AL Bingha AM Neg Neg 3-0
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Novi Quart Monmouth HM Rochester CH Neg Aff 2-1
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Open O4 Cornel AL NYU HP Aff
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Open O3 Monmouth DS Bingha AM Neg
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Novi N2 Binghamton RM Cornell NV Neg
Binghamton October Tournament C 2020-10-16 Open O1 NYU RZ Columbia WW Neg
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 JV R6 Cornell AK Kansas State SW Aff
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 Novi QUART Liberty HJ George Mason BP Neg Neg 3-0
3rd Annual Phyllis Schatz Invitational C 2020-09-25 JV R3 Liberty GJ George Mason RP Neg
Season Opener at Northwestern University C 2020-09-18 Open R4 NYU HP UT Dallas WB Aff
Season Opener at Northwestern University C 2020-09-18 Open R3 Cornell LS Kansas ME Neg
Season Opener at Northwestern University C 2020-09-18 JV RD1 Johnson County Community BB NYU BL Aff