arman omidvar

  • Paradigm
  • Record
Paradigm Statement
Last changed 23 October 2021 1:16 AM PDT

Arman Omidvar

Peninsula 2023

he/him

Id like to be on the email chain if there is one. My email is: armangiveaway@gmail.com

General notes: the rebuttals should be like an RFD, you need to explain a way in which I can feel comfortable voting for you while also taking into account your opponents offense. Please don't just extend arguments from your constructives, I need you to interact with your opponents claims. Debate is either a game or shapes subjectivity, either way please don't be bad people, if you say something messed up I wont hesitate reducing speaks.

AFF:

Plan-less: I'm ok with plan-less affs, I prefer if they be contextualized to the topic. If you're reading high theory, I need a solid explanation in the round that's sufficient enough for me to understand what the argument your going for is. Obviously be prepared to answer FW and have a very good reason as to why you aren't topical. The FW debate is usually the easiest neg ballot so do this well. I really like seeing contextualized and well researched Ks and PIKs against these sorts of affs. If you have one, don't be afraid to go for it.

Soft-left: You need to almost zero the DA and win the CP doesn't solve. Any risk of extinction + a cp that probably solves the aff means easy neg ballot. Framing to me is very important however, I appreciate good analysis and will err towards a certain impact style if you're convincing enough. I need good framing extensions to vote on it, shadow extending "infintarian paralysis" wont cut it.

NEG:

T: If you drop something important, don't make this your 2nr. I'm very tech over truth when evaluating T but I also would like to see legal precision in evidence where it is applicable. - I'm not the best at evaluating T debates that get to techy

K: read one if you have a clear link to the aff other than "state bad". I tend to weigh the aff.

Theory: ill vote on bad theory like ASPEC if you drop it. If that does happen you need to spend a LOT of time in the 1ar justifying why its not a voter and why you should get new answers. I personally believe the neg gets infinite condo but feel free to argue the opposite, I'm happy to vote on it. Don't read embedded ASPEC if its not on the doc.

Full Judging Record
Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Middle School TOC hosted by UK HS 2022-05-13 CX R6 ADL ChHu Padre Pio KK Aff
Middle School TOC hosted by UK MS 2022-05-13 CX R4 Phoenix Country Day PM ADL LT Aff
Middle School TOC hosted by UK MS 2022-05-13 CX R3 Avery Coonley BS ADL CD Neg
Peninsula Invitational HS 2022-01-22 N LD Quar Geffen SM Granada Hills Charter AG Aff Aff 3-0
Peninsula Invitational MS 2022-01-22 N LD Oct ModernBrain EY Harvard-Westlake AM Aff Aff 3-0
Peninsula Invitational MS 2022-01-22 MSCX R3 SA Hudson Yards BZ JTSA BY Neg
Peninsula Invitational MS 2022-01-22 MSCX R2 SA Hudson Yards AL FairSA KL Neg
Peninsula Invitational MS 2022-01-22 MSCX R1 SA East Flatbush RB SA Hudson Yards BG Aff
Middle school CX debates MS 2021-11-12 CX R2 ModernBrain HS ModernBrain TZ Neg
Middle school CX debates MS 2021-11-12 CX R1 ADL CH ModernBrain LQ Aff
Meadows LD Scrimmage 2 HS 2021-10-23 NOVLD R4 Marlborough FM Harvard-Westlake AD Neg
Meadows LD Scrimmage 2 HS 2021-10-23 NOVLD R2 Meadows ZP Peninsula AJ Aff
Scrimmage at Peninsula High School HS 2021-09-25 LD R1 Immaculate Heart SP Peninsula AY Aff
Scrimmage at Peninsula High School HS 2021-09-25 LD R1 Immaculate Heart MF Peninsula AI Neg
Peninsula Invitational MS 2021-01-23 MS CX Final Dougherty Valley Bridge RR SA Ditmas Park PD Neg Neg 3-0
Peninsula Invitational MS 2021-01-23 MS CX Quar SA Ditmas Park JW SA Bronx BM Aff Neg 2-1
Peninsula Invitational MS 2021-01-23 MS CX R4 SA Ditmas Park AC ModernBrain CC Aff
Peninsula Invitational MS 2021-01-23 MS CX R2 Dougherty Valley Bridge RR ModernBrain LZ Aff
Middle School Policy 1025 MS 2020-10-25 CX R3 Modern HL Kinkaid TB Aff
Middle School Policy 1025 MS 2020-10-25 CX R2 Dougherty Valle ZM Modern HT Aff
Middle School Policy 1025 MS 2020-10-25 CX R1 Dougherty Valle MA Modern ST Aff
Middle School Policy 927 MS 2020-09-27 CX R3 Modern KR Dougherty Valle LM Aff
Middle School Policy 927 MS 2020-09-27 CX R2 Dougherty Valle AW Modern HaLi Aff
Middle School Policy 927 MS 2020-09-27 CX R1 Modern HL Dougherty Valle AA Aff Aff 3-0
La Reina Invitational Debate Tournament HS 2019-12-07 MPF R3 Nov42 Wang & Quach & Woo BevVis Patel & Song Aff
La Reina Invitational Debate Tournament HS 2019-12-07 MPF R2 LaRei Fireman & Gama Nov42 Kim & Dashbold Aff
La Reina Invitational Debate Tournament HS 2019-12-07 NLD R2 Nov42 Adam Mimou LaRei Sydney Brea Aff
La Reina Invitational Debate Tournament MS 2019-12-07 NLD R1 Presti Jameson Wilke Nov42 Adam Mimou Neg