Lillian Lingenfelter Paradigm

Last changed 8 January 2021 9:21 AM CDT

I debated for 3 years in high school and 1 year in college and currently coach at Peabody-Burns High School.

I almost always am a policymaker with some exceptions when it comes to kritiks.

I prefer any impact other than nuclear war. I'll listen to nuclear war impacts on DAs, and I've voted for them but I have to be able to see a clear connection on why the voting for the aff would cause a war, the links need to be very strong. As a policymaker I want to be able to evaluate how the plan would hypothetically affect people which is why I tend to prefer smaller magnitude impacts that let me weigh the benefits of the aff with the potential harm to individuals. Also on DAs, I highly value uniqueness. If you're going to run a generic link, at the very least have super recent evidence. Same goes for specific links as well; recency will almost never hurt you, but old evidence will.

As for topicality, I don't mind it and have voted on it before but to win on T alone with me you'd have to do significant work on the voters. I will not vote on T because the neg thinks the aff might be abusive, you have to be committed to this strategy all the way to persuade me to move away from a policymaker framework to examine topicality.

I don't enjoy counterplans but I'm not opposed to them. If you think that a CP is your best strategy in that round then by all means go for it, just know that I almost always will think that there are better arguments to have made. On the aff, I don't want you to read every perm in the book. Do some solid work on theory and I will likely buy it.

Kritiks are important and have some place in debate. That said I don't want to hear a K every round, but I am familiar with most literature and as I said above value arguments that allow me to weigh the aff with the impacts on individual people. The role of the ballot is very important to me, along with being able to do the analysis on your own without just reading a block at me. You will need to do a significant amount of work to get to move me from policymaking to kritiks, however if you think this is your best strategy I trust your judgement, just show me it is your strongest argument.

As for the aff, I don't like K affs, and I prefer a lot of advantages (scenarios). I believe affs should read a plan text. Don't get too overwhelmed by the neg and forget about your case. Far too frequently I see affs that have totally lost track of their advantages by the 1AR. I will not weigh your advantages against the neg if you left them untouched after the 1AC.

In general, I'm not picky on your speed, I'll flow the round so please be very clear on what arguments you are making and where on the flow you want them. I will flow however you want as long as you tell me what argument/card goes where. I like a strong impact calc throughout the round. Anyone can read cards, I value the analysis of if the proposed policy is good or bad and why. There's more to that than just reading the evidence.

If you have questions about specific arguments or want more information about something you can ask me before the round or email me at llingenfelter@usd398.com

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
KSHSAA 4 Speaker State HS 2021-01-15 321A R7 7 Aff 8 Neg Aff Neg 2-1
KSHSAA 4 Speaker State HS 2021-01-15 321A R6 8 Aff 2 Neg Aff Aff 3-0
KSHSAA 4 Speaker State HS 2021-01-15 321A R3 4 Aff 1 Neg Neg Aff 2-1
Kansas Sunflower Novice State Invitational HS 2021-01-08 Nov Octs Blue Valley SJ Blue Valley West KD Aff Neg 2-1
Kansas Sunflower Novice State Invitational HS 2021-01-08 NOp R6 Topeka Seaman BY Olathe Northwest ES Neg
Kansas Sunflower Novice State Invitational HS 2021-01-08 NOp R5 Olathe Northwest KU Shawnee Mission West PF Neg
Kansas Sunflower Novice State Invitational HS 2021-01-08 NOp R1 Topeka Seaman CE Newton VT Neg
Maize High Tournament of Champions Classic Rock Star Wars HS 2020-12-04 JV RD 2 Manhattan NaPu Olathe East BT Aff
Maize High Tournament of Champions Classic Rock Star Wars HS 2020-12-04 JV RD 1 De Soto PT Olathe North GJ Aff