John Robe Paradigm

Last changed 12/14 2:53P MDT

Hi! I'm a very TAB judge, who's relatively new at judging debate; however I have a good amount of experience with Policy and PF as I did those two events as varsity in High School, taking state for Policy.

For Policy debate, I will judge Aff on their holding up of the stock issues (DA, Solvency, Harms, Inherency, Topicality). If AFF drops at least one stock issue, they will lose the round. I will judge contentions based on the cards presented (w/ author/date credibility), effectiveness of arguments, and number of cards and contentions flowed through. At the end of the round, the stock issues win/loss will be determined based on how many arguments flow through to the end.

I understand spewing/spreading, and I understand the reasoning behind it. BUT; if you spew/spread please ensure you slow down on the header of each card and contention, otherwise I may miss your argument and not get it flowed on my paper. If you're spewing too fast, and aren't clear on your points just know that I might miss something (and for policy you don't want your judge to miss something).

Full Judging Record

Tournament Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Utah Region 4 2/23/2019 OCX R1 AC 120 AA 146 Neg
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 CX R6 298 308 Aff Aff on a 3-0
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 CX R5 288 325 Aff Neg on a 2-1
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 CX R4 269 324 Aff
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 CX R3 301 248 Aff
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 CX R2 330 270 Neg
Sundance District Tournament 2/9/2019 PF R1 297 278 Aff
Marie Clegg Jones Memorial 1/25/2019 CX R3 ProHal Skeels & Kalmar Roy Chidester & Pippin Aff
Marie Clegg Jones Memorial 1/25/2019 CX R2 JuaDie Anaya & Brunisholz ProHal Wheeler & Medeiros Aff
Marie Clegg Jones Memorial 1/25/2019 CX R1 RowHal Dau & Park Hillcr Rohde & Middlemas Aff
Knights Joust at Lone Peak 1/11/2019 LD-O R3 Lone Peak James Taylor Salem Hills Brooklyn Nielson Neg
Red Rock Classic 12/14/2018 CX R3 AG Knapp & Devenport AJ Holman & Carlson Aff
Red Rock Classic 12/14/2018 CX R2 AG Gallacher & Kearns AC Maldonado & Robertson Neg
Red Rock Classic 12/14/2018 Parli R1 AG Johnson & Ingram AG sorensen & tasker Aff
Red Rock Classic 12/14/2018 LD R1 AG Kaylee Reinitz AC Alejandra Vitela Aff
Young Lawyers 10/12/2018 NCX R3 Juan Diego Catholic FR Skyline AS Neg
Young Lawyers 10/12/2018 NCX R2 SLC West HP Green Canyon GO Aff
Young Lawyers 10/12/2018 NCX R1 Green Canyon EP Bingham PH Aff