Alex Nagin Paradigm

Last changed 5 April 2021 7:51 AM EDT

ZOOM FOR APRIL 6th:

Alex Nagin is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.

Topic: Alex Nagin's Personal Meeting Room

Join Zoom Meeting

https://zoom.us/j/3514777362?pwd=RWEyb3gxS2dFWG96VDFVOVR6d3I4dz09

Meeting ID: 351 477 7362

Passcode: 1jW4Iu

National University of Mongolia '26

Rhodes Scholar, Harvard Dentistry graduate, Deputy National Security advisor.

Before I get into any part of this paradigm, if you are sexist, homophobic, racist, xenophobic, ableist, or anything else that targets someone's identity, you will be dropped, no questions asked.

I'm down for weird/niche arguments, anything can win if you weigh it well. Also, I think theory/K's are fine as long as they are used to actually advance and develop our understanding of why certain aspects of debate/the resolution are flawed and not because you think it's an easier path to my ballot.

Please signpost clearly so I know where you are on the flow. Extend, and do comparative weighing/analysis too. It's not helpful to me if you just say that you're winning the round because you impact to more people.

Be careful about frontlining every turn that the other teams read, if its a really messy round that neither team is really winning I may be inclined to vote on a turn/de-link that was dropped in summary.

truth>tech. Not many judges have this philosophy (maybe some parent ones do) but I believe strongly in it. Debate should be an educational activity that assesses world topics on a realistic level. NSDA selects resolutions that have true arguments on both sides that can win you the round. Evaluating rounds on simply tech is bad for education and leads debaters down rabbit holes that aren't constructive to building an intellectual understanding of the resolution at hand.

Please note that I really hate when debaters go too hard on perceptual dominance in CX. Just have a fair and civil discussion about why you think their arguments are flawed.

Default speaks 28.5

Bubble tea references IN SPEECH +0.5 speaker points.

Mongolia references are an instant 30. No I'm not kidding. I am fascinated with the country and I would like you to incorporate it into your speech. However, I will only give you a 30 if I feel this is the case. I'm not afraid of low point wins.

Don't:

- Scream

- Postround

- Be annoying

- Talk over people

- Say "game over"

Also I agree with everything in Chuck Stubbins' Paradigm:

"I DON'T KNOW MUCH ABOUT THE HIGH FALUTIN' THINGS Y'ALL TALKIN' ABOUT BUT I CAN TELL YOU I AM GREATLY CONCERNED WITH HOW THESE THINGS IMPACT THE BUS ROUTE I GOTTA DRIVE AT 4:45AM EVERY MORNIN' TO GET THESE KIDS TO SCHOOL

LOT OF KIDS TALK ABOUT TEA, WHICH IS FINE WITH ME AS LONG AS YOU BOILED IT TO LET ALL THE SUGAR GET IN THERE OR ELSE I DON'T WANT IT

I HAVEN'T HAD A PERM SINCE KENNY LOGGINS SANG DANGER ZONE AT MY WEDDING, SO I AM UNFAMILIAR AT BEST

I AM OPEN TO CRITIQUE, BUT I MUST SAY THERE IS A FINE LINE BETWEEN HELPIN' A MAN AND LEAVIN' HIM TO FEND FOR HIS LIFE AGAINST A PACK OF FERAL HOGS WITHOUT PROPER ASSISTANCE *RIP BARTHOLOMEW "SCOOTER" JENKINS* AS SUCH MY TOLERANCE FOR ANY RABBLE ROUSIN' WITH THE CRITICISMS IS QUITE LOW OUT OF RESPECT TO THE JENKINS FAMILY, LORD BLESS

MY BUS HAS A GOVERNOR ON IT LIMITING ME TO A ROBUST SPEED OF 55 MILES AN HOUR, IF YOU'RE READING SO FAST AS TO GET THROUGH THE PREAMBLE TO THE CONSTITUTION BEFORE I CAN MAKE IT THROUGH A LOOP IN THE BUS DROP OFF, YOU'RE GOING TOO FAST.

NO LOLLYGAGGIN', DILLYDALLYIN', BUMBLESCOOTIN', KNICKER-KNOTTIN', EGG-SUCKIN', DILL-PICKLIN', GOOSE-GETTIN', HOT DOGGIN' OR HATE SPEECHIN' OF ANY KIND. WORLD FULL OF PLENTY OF RASCALS AND DEMONS, YA AIN'T GOTTA BE ONE OF 'EM GOD BLESS.

I LOOK FORWARD TO THE PRESTIGE OF LEARNING HOW YOUR ARGUMENTS IMPACT MY WORLD OF PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION AND WISH YOU THE MOST HIGHEST OF PRAISE UNDER THE SUN.

Y'ALL STAY FINER THAN A FROG'S HAIR SPLIT THREE WAYS NOW."

Full Judging Record

Tournament Lv Date Ev Rd Aff Neg Vote Result
Horace Mann Invitational HS 2021-01-24 R2 Horace Mann FR Horace Mann KS Aff
Horace Mann Invitational HS 2021-01-24 Round Horace Mann CS Horace Mann BL Aff
Ridge Debates HS 2020-12-11 NPF Partia Delbarton EF Hunter FY Con Con 2-1
Ridge Debates HS 2020-12-11 NPF R5 Regis CM Sharon HX Con
Ridge Debates HS 2020-12-11 NPF R4 Princeton CS Trinity MF Pro
Ridge Debates HS 2020-12-11 NPF R3 Sharon MK Regis TT Pro
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2020-10-15 PFJV R2 Summit FA Bronx Science NZ Pro
New York City Invitational Debate and Speech Tournament HS 2020-10-15 PFJV R1 Quarry Lane PaWa College Prep DesSak Pro